From: Susono, Japan Registered: 2006-06-23 Posts: 864 Website
Slight glitch when browsing by keyword. If you type 'remote' into the box, two keywords come up 'permanence/remote 958' and 'remote 2419'. Regardless of which one I select it takes me to frame 2419. Obviously it is easy enough to pull the other frame up by just entering the frame number...but I assume it should allow you to find it by keyword too.
At frame 2419 astridtops wrote "Another double with RTKI " I don't know any other duplicates but I wonder if they have this same feature.
The other double I came across so far is deviate/elude (1973) vs elude (2416). And indeed if you try to go to deviate/elude (1973) it will take you to elude (2416) instead, so it is a problem for all the cases where the 4th edition RTK1 key word change is still present in the 3th edition RTK3. So far I can remember only those two examples, but I'm only halfway RTK3, so there might be more.
Add dedicate to that: observance/dedicate(1573) vs. dedicate(2265). The latter adds the fingers primitive to the former. I was removing all 3rd edition keywords when I noticed this. These are the only three instances of 4th edition keywords clashing with RTK3 keywords. Does Heisig offer alternatives for them to bring them in line with his RTK1 4th edition?
BTW, by removing the 3rd edition keywords using the Substitute Keywords script, the effect is reversed: You're always taken to the page of the first keyword. *shrug*
*edit* The magic number is 2042, not 2024. Faulty info removed. *edit*
The 5th edition adds explanation/interpretation(1908) vs. interpretation(2263) (no visual resemblance), as well as shifting a few keywords around: masculine becomes male (743), male becomes man (859); rumor becomes explanation (499), explanation becomes interpretation (1908).
The latter is not such a problem, since the keywords remain unique within a single edition (it makes searching a little more troublesome), but the former I don't like much. We can wait until a new edition of RTK3 comes out (any rumors?) or come up with our own set in the meantime. Proposals?