Has Japan Let You Down?

Index » General discussion

Zon70 Member
From: USA Registered: 2010-05-25 Posts: 89

I went to japan and the only thing that I was let down about the whole experience was that i couldnt get a work visa. my only chance is a spouse visa. japan is a lot better than america and i cant wait to go back and this time as a resident.

trickster9 New member
From: tokushima Registered: 2011-07-12 Posts: 1

Japan hasn't let me down.  I've let Japan down.  Sorry Japan...

Asriel Member
From: 東京 Registered: 2008-02-26 Posts: 1343

Zon70 wrote:

I went to japan and the only thing that I was let down about the whole experience was that i couldnt get a work visa. my only chance is a spouse visa. japan is a lot better than america and i cant wait to go back and this time as a resident.

Really? Why couldn't you get a work visa?
Do you have a Japanese spouse, or serious significant other who's Japanese?

Advertising (register and sign in to hide this)
JapanesePod101 Sponsor
 
Zon70 Member
From: USA Registered: 2010-05-25 Posts: 89

Asriel wrote:

Zon70 wrote:

I went to japan and the only thing that I was let down about the whole experience was that i couldnt get a work visa. my only chance is a spouse visa. japan is a lot better than america and i cant wait to go back and this time as a resident.

Really? Why couldn't you get a work visa?
Do you have a Japanese spouse, or serious significant other who's Japanese?

cause i got no 資格 (according to the japanese governments definiton of qualifications anyways) no i dont have a japanese spouse or significant other,  i only said that because i am trying to hold a postive attidute that eventually i willl find one!(couldnt find one in japan, but hopefully i will on the internet haha)

ps
there is one part i forgot to leave out , japan did leave me down when i found out there is no place to sit without paying(in tokyo anyways) and a severe lack of trash cans

Last edited by Zon70 (2012 February 01, 7:11 pm)

Jarvik7 Member
From: 名古屋 Registered: 2007-03-05 Posts: 3946

I believe there have been studies that show that the presence of public trashcans actually encourages littering.

The trashcans inevitably fill up and overflow or tip over and spill their contents, leaving garbage on the ground. When someone sees the garbage on the ground, they don't feel bad about adding to it as they would throwing garbage on the clean ground.

Anyways, you get used to it pretty quick (carry your garbage with you until you hit up a konbini).

Asriel Member
From: 東京 Registered: 2008-02-26 Posts: 1343

Zon70 wrote:

cause i got no 資格 (according to the japanese governments definiton of qualifications anyways) no i dont have a japanese spouse or significant other,  i only said that because i am trying to hold a postive attidute that eventually i willl find one!(couldnt find one in japan, but hopefully i will on the internet haha)

OK, fair enough. I wasn't sure if it was something like that, or you somehow pissed off the government and they had shut you off or something.

Aah yes, finding Japanese girls online. I remember that thread...

Jarvik7 wrote:

I believe there have been studies that show that the presence of public trashcans actually encourages littering.

I can definitely believe this. I was less inclined to bring things along that I knew I would have to throw away if I knew I would have to carry it around. Thinks like candy bars, onigiri.. you know, snacks. That's one reason I liked having a basket on my bike.

chochajin Member
From: Japan Registered: 2008-07-13 Posts: 520 Website

thejoshlord wrote:

I cant imagine how that would feel, spend the last few years learning Japanese finding out you don't like the country.

Sorry, I don't really get it.
Are you saying you ONLY study Japanese in order to be in the country in the end?
That's sad. I'm sure there are a lot of people who have other reasons as well.

Some people study Japanese without ever coming here at all.

Why would you be disappointed if you don't like the country?
It doesn't change the fact that you've studied a lot of Japanese and progressed, right?

Diana Member
From: USA Registered: 2008-01-22 Posts: 70

Also for comparison, do Japanese people make fun of people with broken Japanese?

It's interesting because on the one hand, people in English countries demand foreigners to hurry up, learn English and assimilate, while on the other hand, making fun of their broken English (Engrish.com, "Me Love You Rong Time" etc) or in extreme cases, treat someone negatively BECAUSE of their less-than-perfect English (companies with foreign call centers for example).


Yes, and yes.
Happens all the time at my company, happens in high school, happened in university to me here.

aphasiac Member
From: 台湾 Registered: 2009-03-16 Posts: 1036

Diana wrote:

Also for comparison, do Japanese people make fun of people with broken Japanese?

It's interesting because on the one hand, people in English countries demand foreigners to hurry up, learn English and assimilate, while on the other hand, making fun of their broken English (Engrish.com, "Me Love You Rong Time" etc) or in extreme cases, treat someone negatively BECAUSE of their less-than-perfect English (companies with foreign call centers for example).


Yes, and yes.
Happens all the time at my company, happens in high school, happened in university to me here.

There are Japanese TV stars who are only famous for their bad Japanese. Put them on TV, get them to speak and then laugh at the funny gaijin with their poor language skills! Bobby Ologun is a well know example.

kitakitsune Member
From: Tokyo Registered: 2008-10-19 Posts: 1006

They actually ran a hidden camera show that proved that Bobby was actually very fluent in Japanese. And by really good I mean he was able to spot typos in ridiculously long legal contracts and name dropping obscure 19th century novelists.

Jarvik7 Member
From: 名古屋 Registered: 2007-03-05 Posts: 3946

Bobby is more famous as a geinoujin because he is a giant scary looking black man with violent outbursts (and a former pro wrestler). The lack of Japanese skill is just an expectation that goes along with that. If he was on TV in America he would probably speak like a caveman.

Wes1378 Member
From: United States Registered: 2011-03-28 Posts: 12

This happens to a lot of people. Sometimes quickly, sometimes after a while. One thing that really got to me in Japan was the lack of diversity. I am American and I see every culture reflected in all the businesses, architecture, people, etc around me every day.
If you are not in certain areas of Tokyo, like the Roppongi hills area,  than everything is Japanese.  This is awesome until you start to miss the whole other world of diversity. Japanese people are very nationalistic too. Many visitors tend to feel like outsiders even if the have been living in Japan for many years, or decades.
There are many people making videos and blogs about there experiences living in Japan. Mixed in with all the folks who are really enjoying themselves will be quite a few people who are ready to return home. It's very important to get this perspective too.

aphasiac Member
From: 台湾 Registered: 2009-03-16 Posts: 1036

kitakitsune wrote:

They actually ran a hidden camera show that proved that Bobby was actually very fluent in Japanese. And by really good I mean he was able to spot typos in ridiculously long legal contracts and name dropping obscure 19th century novelists.

The wikipedia entry notes this, saying "feigned confusion". I remember seeing that clip on youtube; he spots a kanji error on a girls t-shirt and then a couple more spelling errors on the contract he is signing.

Jarvik7 wrote:

Bobby is more famous as a geinoujin because he is a giant scary looking black man with violent outbursts (and a former pro wrestler). The lack of Japanese skill is just an expectation that goes along with that. If he was on TV in America he would probably speak like a caveman.

Is there an equivalent to Bobby on TV in America?

Closest I can think of in the UK is Borat, but he was an obviously fake comedy character.

oyajijeff New member
From: Japan Registered: 2012-01-18 Posts: 9

I have lived in Japan for many years and I would leave tomorrow if I could. But my wife and kids are Japanese and that would mean leaving them behind, which I won't do. So I just make the best of it.

There are many good things about Japan and the Japanese in general, but then again you can say that about EVERY culture and people, so nothing special here.

But what has ground on me over the years is the extreme immaturity of Japanese. And that is reflected no better than on Japanese TV, which is god awful. With the exception of a few good dramas and documentaries, TV here is at the level of an 11 year old, and the Japanese love it.

Take a trip to Tokyo Disney Land, where you'll find perfectly sane adult women and men wearing their Mickey Mouse ears and running around acting like, well....11 year olds.

Watch a food show where after every bite the participants act as if they have just tasted the best food ever created in the history of mankind.

Try joining a sports club where you have to decide on the 5 day a week course, weekend only course, night time only course, sunny day only course, every other cloudy day course, etc. Can't I just pay my monthly fee and workout?

Japan is also very very boring. There really isn't a whole lot to do here beside going out to eat and drink. As far as sightseeing....the crowds, the prices...no thanks.

I could go on and on...my advice; stay away. A short visit or business trip? Ok I guess. But to live here. Fail.

Japan Sucks

fakewookie Member
From: London Registered: 2010-08-02 Posts: 362

oyajijeff wrote:

I have lived in Japan for many years and I would leave tomorrow if I could. But my wife and kids are Japanese and that would mean leaving them behind, which I won't do. So I just make the best of it.

There are many good things about Japan and the Japanese in general, but then again you can say that about EVERY culture and people, so nothing special here.

But what has ground on me over the years is the extreme immaturity of Japanese. And that is reflected no better than on Japanese TV, which is god awful. With the exception of a few good dramas and documentaries, TV here is at the level of an 11 year old, and the Japanese love it.

Take a trip to Tokyo Disney Land, where you'll find perfectly sane adult women and men wearing their Mickey Mouse ears and running around acting like, well....11 year olds.

Watch a food show where after every bite the participants act as if they have just tasted the best food ever created in the history of mankind.

Try joining a sports club where you have to decide on the 5 day a week course, weekend only course, night time only course, sunny day only course, every other cloudy day course, etc. Can't I just pay my monthly fee and workout?

Japan is also very very boring. There really isn't a whole lot to do here beside going out to eat and drink. As far as sightseeing....the crowds, the prices...no thanks.

I could go on and on...my advice; stay away. A short visit or business trip? Ok I guess. But to live here. Fail.

Japan Sucks

How's your Japanese?

oyajijeff New member
From: Japan Registered: 2012-01-18 Posts: 9

I stand by my rant queer, qweer? 17 years living here has afforded me that.

Asriel Member
From: 東京 Registered: 2008-02-26 Posts: 1343

I disagree, qwertyytrewq, his post was quite valid. Just because he didn't hit on any of the "big hitters" doesn't make it any less of a good argument. He mentioned gripes he has with it in his day-to-day life. Ask me about what I dislike about my current living situation, and I assure you I wouldn't touch on any of those topics.

Japanese TV sucks. It really does. Maybe it's different if you have more than the standard 7 channels, but it's all shit -- worse than American TV. Over here you'll at least have something somewhat decent during primetime. Japanese TV is levels below it.
And the shows about food... It's not just necessarily just "if they're eating food on TV, of course they're going to like it," it's more like "why are they eating food on every channel? Regardless of what show it is?" It's all over the place.

I can't comment on the other things -- about the sports club, and being boring, etc... But it's certainly the day-in-day-out concerns that determines how content I am with my life. Maybe I'm too self-centered, but whatever.

thistime Member
Registered: 2008-11-04 Posts: 223

oyajijeff wrote:

Japan is also very very boring. There really isn't a whole lot to do here beside going out to eat and drink. As far as sightseeing....the crowds, the prices...no thanks.

This is a very good point. Japan is boring. As boring as any other country. I think this is where the, "my life sucks here, but if I move to Japan it will be a non-stop party and I'll be the most popular kid in town" folks find themselves very disallusioned.

95% of your life in Japan is going to involve waking up, getting ready, going to work, working, coming home, eating dinner, watching TV, going to bed and then waking up and doing it all over again the next day. That's life in pretty much any 1st world country.

I'm not sure what you had back home that you don't have here that made your life more entertaining but Japan has museums, sports, shopping, shows, movies, tourist attractions, just like any other developped country.

And aside from movies, I think all other things are pretty comparable in price. And yes, you do need to avoid weekends and national holidays if you want to avoid crowds but that's also true of almost anywhere.

Though, I will admit that one thing that really bums me out is special exhibits at museums. They are so crowded you can't get anywhere near the pieces to actually see them. There have been many exhibits that I would have loved to have seen but it just wasn't even worth going because I knew what the crowds would be like.

thistime Member
Registered: 2008-11-04 Posts: 223

Asriel wrote:

I

Japanese TV sucks. It really does. Maybe it's different if you have more than the standard 7 channels, but it's all shit -- worse than American TV. Over here you'll at least have something somewhat decent during primetime. Japanese TV is levels below it.
And the shows about food... It's not just necessarily just "if they're eating food on TV, of course they're going to like it," it's more like "why are they eating food on every channel? Regardless of what show it is?" It's all over the place.

Yes, this is true. Japanese TV sucks worse than American TV (which is pretty crappy already) but I think that comes down to bucks. America has WAAAY more money to pump into each show than Japan ever will.

And I totally agree about the food thing. That totally grates on my nerves. It is near impossible to find a TV show where people aren't talking about food, cooking food, eating food, visiting restaurants, buying food, watching people eat food, even if the show has nothing to do with food at all. It's so annoying, but whatever. The Japanese are obsessed with food, that's not going to change any time soon.

Mennon Member
From: Okazaki Registered: 2008-12-11 Posts: 38

Great question. I came here for no real reason other than have a bit of fun, and I stayed, so I had no expectations. I didn't read manga or watch anime or anything. Couldn't speak Japanese. So I don't think I have been let down.
But having been here so long, I do get disappointed quite often. I think if people want to complain about multiculturalism, spend a year in Japan first. Or any monoculture. Everyone thinks the same. Everyone says the same thing. Everyone dresses the same. Everyone asks the same questions. And spare me the exceptions. They are so few and far between they are basically insignificant. Living in a culture which has no capacity to change, for better or worse, there is absolutely nothing at stake here. It's funny, they have a weak nostalgia for the Showa era, the 60's basically, yet it can never catch on because it is still basically the same. There are 120 million well educated, healthy people here, but not one of them can change this place. You begin to look at America a little differently, and see how vibrant and passionate it is. Or even the Middle East, where people are being shot protesting for a better life for their children. Here? Jeez, I dunno, engineering better wanking tools? Slippers for pets? This place is an alien ship, protected from the world and worldly things. And they wouldn't have it any other way. They are the Borg.
But hey, I'm not one of them, so big deal right? But I have two kids now, and that's different, and I'm a week away from getting them out of this place.

aphasiac Member
From: 台湾 Registered: 2009-03-16 Posts: 1036

oyajijeff wrote:

Watch a food show where after every bite the participants act as if they have just tasted the best food ever created in the history of mankind.

haha I agree with the original point; the reactions to food on these shows are ridiculous. They take a mouthful, then its like "MMMMMM, OOIIISHIIIII" with a "pleasurable" look/stare to the camera. It's so over the top and exaggerated it's actually pretty comical; it's actually more reaction than you find in most J-AVs..

qwertyytrewq, do you live in Japan? I don't really think you can "prove" someone's personal views are wrong; oyajijeffis entitled to his opinion. You can only really counter with your own (more positive) experiences.

Last edited by aphasiac (2012 February 01, 11:20 pm)

ronnihonjin New member
From: Japan Registered: 2012-01-31 Posts: 9

"I don't follow Japanese news but has there been any high profile race-motivated murders there, similar to the ones that you hear about in the USA once a month?"


There are plenty of examples of Japanese nationals murdering foreigners. They often do not become very high profile cases, if they are even picked u by the local media at all.

Hoon "Scott" Kang, a Korean-American national was found dead in the stairwell of a Kabukicho building. Despite video evidence to the contrary and protests from his family, his death is being treated by Tokyo Metropolitan police as accidental.

Lindsey Hawker, British national raped and murdered. Her killer miraculously avoided the death penalty and has even managed to release a book while he has been incarcerated. A new movie is also in the works about his life on the run, despite the protests of the Hawker family. The Hawker case is also notable as it highlights something I mentioned previously, poor translation/interpretation services offered by the courts, in this instance those provided to the Hawker family themselves.

Issei Sagawa, Japanese national who killed, raped and consumed a Dutch woman in that order. He was extradited back to Japan and promptly released. Since then he has enjoyed a macabre celebrity, writing restaurant reviews for magazines, acting in such high brow productions as Uwakizuma: Chijokuzeme (Unfaithful Wife: Shameful Torture), taking part in talk shows and painting and selling nude pictures of women.

Edward N. Allshouse, Jr., 17, An American High school student in Okinawa was murdered following an argument over a girl.

Bishnu Prasad Dhamala, A Neplaese beaten to death on a street in Osaka two weeks ago, despite offering no resistance to his attackers whatsoever. He was kicked repeatedly about the head before a bicycle was dropped on his head as he lay prostrate on the ground. Following his death, his assailants asserted in statements that they did not expect the foreigner to die. Whether this means they believed that foreigners were able to take more of a beating than the average Japanese is quite unclear...

ABUBAKAR AWUDU SURAJ, a Ghanian national murdered during his deportation by Japanese immigration officials. He was married to a Japanese national and had been in Japan for 22 years, but a brief visa overstay in the 1980s rendered him liable for deportation. The incident involved such Monty Python esque farce as immigration officers bringing their own plastic restraints from home and attempting to convince the cabin crew of an Air Egypt flight, that the man they had murdered in their custody, was merely "pretending to be sick" when said crew refused to transport his body. As yet no immigration officials have been indicted for his death. The Economist also made some interesting comments about The SRP system

"The SRP system is an example of the problem. No criteria for eligibility are specified. Instead, published “guidelines” are applied arbitrarily. And people cannot apply directly for an SRP: illegal residents can only request it once in detention, or turn themselves in and try their luck while deportation proceedings are under way. So most illegal residents just stay mum. Mr Suraj fell into the SRP abyss after he was arrested for overstaying his visa. Although he had lived in Japan for 22 years, was fluent in the language and married to a Japanese citizen, his SRP request was denied. "


His wife was also not informed about his deportation and only found out about it after he was already dead ‘‘I have yet to receive any apologies. I want to know what happened,’’

A pretty decent article about the whole affair
http://www.economist.com/node/16113280


Plenty more of these around as well....

Last edited by ronnihonjin (2012 February 01, 11:49 pm)

Mennon Member
From: Okazaki Registered: 2008-12-11 Posts: 38

qwertyytrewq You don't get my point because you are intentionally misreading it, or too busy masturbating.
Your views aren't really views at all. I think cows should shit vegetables, but I do perceive that there is a reality outside of myself and try adjust my views accordingly. Go and protest your local Neo Nazi faction and make your dream a reality. I hope they beat the shit out of you, coward.
PS you would love it here, you and your pimply gaijin buddies. But with mommy not around to buy you decent clothes you still can't get a date. I see guys like you at the train stations all the time.

ronnihonjin New member
From: Japan Registered: 2012-01-31 Posts: 9

Oh, almost forgot to mention,

Govinda Prasad Mainali, Nepalese national, who was "falsely" accused and convicted of the murder of Yasuko Watanabe, despite purely circumstancial evidence. Recent (the evidence was hidden by prosecutors at the time of the original trial) DNA tests have further confirmed his innocence, despite a ruling by the Supreme court to the contrary in 2003. As of yet he still sits languishing in a Japanese prison.

Reply #100 - 2012 February 02, 2:16 am
Surreal Member
From: Sweden Registered: 2009-05-18 Posts: 325

Hyperborea wrote:

ronnihonjin wrote:

Oh, almost forgot to mention,

Govinda Prasad Mainali, Nepalese national, who was "falsely" accused and convicted of the murder of Yasuko Watanabe, despite purely circumstancial evidence. Recent (the evidence was hidden by prosecutors at the time of the original trial) DNA tests have further confirmed his innocence, despite a ruling by the Supreme court to the contrary in 2003. As of yet he still sits languishing in a Japanese prison.

The plural of anecdote is not data.

WHAT. Are you trying to say that what hyperborea posted doesn't mean anything, because they're isolated cases? Don't you think that the fact that these kinds of cases, and the reactions (like the none too unusual firing of innocents that are somehow related to the incident) are allowed to happen means something?

Moreover, he was replying to the question "I don't follow Japanese news but has there been any high profile race-motivated murders there, similar to the ones that you hear about in the USA once a month?", so your comment makes NO SENSE.

I don't want to answer in place of ronnihonjin but your post really just made me angry. What the hell, dude?