howtwosavealif3 wrote:
don't lots of people like them polyglots try to avoid using dictionaries
While there is a lot to be said for not leaning on the dictionary too much, the pronunciation can not really be deduced from reading Japanese unless you are reading a work with full furigana. There are certainly trends and the more you know the better you can guess, but unlike phonetic languages where mistakes are minor and easily recognized the first (or next) time you hear the word, a mistake in interpreting the pronunciation in Japanese could be a completely different reading. I find myself reaching for the dictionary a lot more often when reading a novel than a manga - I can blip over a word once, stabbing a guess at the meaning from kanji and context, but if it's repeated I just have to look it up. (Probably because I pronounce in my head as, for example, 'probably かん as in China, じ as in letter' which is an awfully long and disruptive phrase to subvocalize, or else as the known common verb readings associated with each character in other cases, which is slightly less disruptive but still nags at me that I need to look it up sometime.)
I try not to reach for my dictionary when I'm sure of the reading but hazy on the meaning (I have a lot of words like that for various reasons that mostly sum up to years of haphazard studying). There are plenty of full furigana manga, of course, (also a source of many words that I learned the reading but not the meaning... ), but there is a potential that people will look down on you for reading comics (which is odd because they'll be in awe if you read an easy light novel and contemptuous of you if you read a much more challenging manga... not sure how many light novels have furigana, but then there are juvenile novels that do. There's also the Furigana Times, though I've never subscribed.) Of course, being looked down on matters in any concrete sense only when the workplace is somewhere you're developing your career, or if there's a chance the supervisor would react differently and, say, ban the comic books while permitting novels or newspapers.
There are, I should mention... paper dictionaries. I used Shogakukan Progressive until I invested in an electronic dictionary, and it's true that they are slower but - once you are used to kana-order - no slower than looking things up on the 'net on a 3G phone. Considerably slower than looking things up on a real computer and network connection, and completely blown away by an electronic dictionary, but, eh. Well, except when your first stab or two at pronunciation are wrong ... paper character dictionaries are a nightmare, really. The Grammar Dictionary series is also a good paper study that can be opened at random for a few minutes of study, and a useful resource to have around besides.
Last edited by SomeCallMeChris (2011 December 05, 12:33 am)