On frame 1511 I just realized that I've been writing 田 wrong

Index » RtK Volume 1

  • 1
 
Apache Chief Member
Registered: 2011-02-04 Posts: 39

I've been writing it like 日 with a vertical line through it. Apparently this is not correct.
Oops.

steelmole Member
From: UK Registered: 2008-09-21 Posts: 16

A similar thing happened to me.  Don't worry about it, it took about a week to fix.

This is one of the brilliant things about the Heisig method, if you realise you've been making a mistake in one primitive you only have to fix it once, and all the characters that use it are also magically fixed.

TwoMoreCharacters Member
From: Sweden Registered: 2010-07-10 Posts: 480

You mean you wrote the horizontal line in the middle first? I did that too.

You're supposed to do it for 里 though.

Advertising (register and sign in to hide this)
JapanesePod101 Sponsor
 
SammyB Member
From: Sydney, Australia Registered: 2008-05-28 Posts: 337

TwoMoreCharacters wrote:

You mean you wrote the horizontal line in the middle first? I did that too.

You're supposed to do it for 里 though.

Yeah me too... I think it's because of 里 and 専, etc that made me write the horizontal stroke in 田 first... It doesn't really make sense to have two different orders. If I am concentrating I will do it correctly but otherwise I am not even aware I'm doing it wrong.

AlexandreC Member
From: Canada Registered: 2008-09-26 Posts: 309

That would be the Chinese stroke order.

TwoMoreCharacters Member
From: Sweden Registered: 2010-07-10 Posts: 480

Yes.

six8ten Member
Registered: 2011-02-26 Posts: 106

Unless somebody is watching you write it and you're paranoid that they may realize you aren't the epitome of anal retentive perfection, or you're planning on doing calligraphy, no big deal. End result looks the same.

Apache Chief Member
Registered: 2011-02-04 Posts: 39

Yeah, I really don't think it's worth it to try to correct. It will throw my muscle memory off for a while and it won't change anything in the end. I probably would have tried it a few weeks ago, but my lately perfectionism is giving way to a much more practical attitude toward kanji.

jishera Member
From: California Registered: 2011-01-19 Posts: 179

I've had this happen a couple times too. I messed up water when it is on the left side!  Most of the time if I'm unsure I open it up in jisho.org to verify.

Reply #10 - 2011 October 20, 7:07 pm
kainzero Member
From: Los Angeles Registered: 2009-08-31 Posts: 945

six8ten wrote:

Unless somebody is watching you write it and you're paranoid that they may realize you aren't the epitome of anal retentive perfection, or you're planning on doing calligraphy, no big deal. End result looks the same.

knowing the proper stroke order helps a little bit when trying to read some of the cursive/brush kanji.

there is also the possibility of 田 being confused with the right part of 押。
i know it looks way different to you but to some it might look similar (with pen, you can see the middle vertical line creeping a little bit below the bottom horizontal line when you write it incorrectly.)

Reply #11 - 2011 October 20, 9:55 pm
aphasiac Member
From: 台湾 Registered: 2009-03-16 Posts: 1036

AlexandreC wrote:

That would be the Chinese stroke order.

Ah crap! Working through RtH and I've been writing it the Japanese way all this time...now have to try and reset my msucle-memory..

  • 1