Could you learn Japanese in just 3-6 months?

Index » The Japanese language

Reply #26 - 2011 May 12, 1:13 pm
dizmox Member
Registered: 2007-08-11 Posts: 1149

I'd feel like killing myself studying so much.

Reply #27 - 2011 May 12, 1:24 pm
ta12121 Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-06-02 Posts: 3190

Tori-kun wrote:

ta12121 wrote:

To be honest, I'd say you can study for a few hours a day but immerse for hours and hours on end. That's what I did for the first year of studying. Worked really well so far but, you definitely need breaks in-between.

Can't tell, but with me it's at last like that I can't hear the "kawaiiii!~" shout outs after 5 minutes any longer, these high frequencies of female voices is so penetrating, yak. Can't find anything I'd like listen to. I lose interest quite quickly when I don't understand anything. Comparable to Ukrainian TV my parents are watching. As long as it's Russian it's fine, but sometimes they have shows in Ukrainian. After a while I give up and just leave. What to do? Subs2SRS is working pretty well, but though, progress seems to be sooo slow compared to my reading skills T_T I wonder how you did the part of "production", ta. After core6k I will prolly switch my card layout to kana->kanji, in order to be able to write more kanji again smile

haha. I still find those squeaking high-pitched voices annoying. I tend to listen to a lot of guy talk. Although there are a lot of jp girls that have a low-tone voiced(not a male's voice, just not high-pitched. Makes it easier on the ears.)

For the production type cards. I do kana to kanji in my production deck(so far it has kana where I test myself based of sound and vocab words(kana to kanji as I do active recall). Plus you add the RTK keywords into that mix(I actually delete quite a lot of keywords that are not common/don't really have a good meaning in English).

My new srs pace is taking 45mins now. 3 decks. With an average of 300-500 reps per day. A huge difference from 1000-1500 I used to do. It saves a lot of time in the long-run. 20% srsing vs 80% immersion.

Reply #28 - 2011 May 12, 1:26 pm
ta12121 Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-06-02 Posts: 3190

dizmox wrote:

I'd feel like killing myself studying so much.

That's why we need to make it fun. Otherwise it's game over

Advertising (register and sign in to hide this)
JapanesePod101 Sponsor
 
Reply #29 - 2011 May 12, 1:51 pm
KMDES Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-09-28 Posts: 306

ta12121 wrote:

dizmox wrote:

I'd feel like killing myself studying so much.

That's why we need to make it fun. Otherwise it's game over

Except SRSing is never fun. hmm

Reply #30 - 2011 May 12, 2:06 pm
ta12121 Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-06-02 Posts: 3190

KMDES wrote:

ta12121 wrote:

dizmox wrote:

I'd feel like killing myself studying so much.

That's why we need to make it fun. Otherwise it's game over

Except SRSing is never fun. hmm

It's addicting for me. The thought about having so much knowledge for the long-term with only studying a few minutes per day is quite amazing. I've found that you need to spice up what you put into that thing. Rare/fun vocab/interesting and fun sentences. Something enjoyable for you keep to learning and learning. Or maybe it's only fun for me or at least interesting to do.

Reply #31 - 2011 May 12, 2:16 pm
jmignot Member
From: France Registered: 2006-03-03 Posts: 205

Oniichan wrote:

A tip that has been very useful to me has been to learn how to make a conversation flow with "connectors"  http://sites.google.com/site/fluentczec … alintimacy and http://sites.google.com/site/fluentczec … tarterpack

This looks rather handy. Perhaps one could propose an equivalent list in Japanese — this is beyond my current abilities, though hmm

Reply #32 - 2011 May 12, 2:16 pm
KMDES Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-09-28 Posts: 306

ta12121 wrote:

KMDES wrote:

ta12121 wrote:


That's why we need to make it fun. Otherwise it's game over

Except SRSing is never fun. hmm

It's addicting for me. The thought about having so much knowledge for the long-term with only studying a few minutes per day is quite amazing. I've found that you need to spice up what you put into that thing. Rare/fun vocab/interesting and fun sentences. Something enjoyable for you keep to learning and learning. Or maybe it's only fun for me or at least interesting to do.

Yeah, but you're talking to a guy who can't even get addicted to caffeine. Sentences, words etc and only interesting if they have something interesting behind them. And honestly who wants to read 'Hippos sweat pink sweat' in Japanese 20 times even though it was interesting the first time? And of course, when it comes to Anki, you get to repeat those same cards every 8 hours until you decide to just delete the damn program because who wants to do the same card every 8 hours for months and months on end?

Reply #33 - 2011 May 12, 2:20 pm
nest0r Member
Registered: 2007-10-19 Posts: 5236 Website

KMDES wrote:

And of course, when it comes to Anki, you get to repeat those same cards every 8 hours until you decide to just delete the damn program because who wants to do the same card every 8 hours for months and months on end?

Every 8 hours?

Last edited by nest0r (2011 May 12, 2:21 pm)

Reply #34 - 2011 May 12, 2:22 pm
jettyke Member
From: 九州 Registered: 2008-04-07 Posts: 1194

KMDES wrote:

Yeah, but you're talking to a guy who can't even get addicted to caffeine.

Let me solve that: Drink a cup of coffee each time before studying, and during breaks.

Bang it into your head that "you need the next cup of xx to study faster/better/more efficiently"

Then just drink it every time you feel demotivated.

Repeat it for weeks.

Then post the result big_smile

Reply #35 - 2011 May 12, 2:31 pm
KMDES Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-09-28 Posts: 306

nest0r wrote:

KMDES wrote:

And of course, when it comes to Anki, you get to repeat those same cards every 8 hours until you decide to just delete the damn program because who wants to do the same card every 8 hours for months and months on end?

Every 8 hours?

Every 8 hours.

It's the curse of Anki. No matter what button I press. No matter what I set the settings at. No matter what, it's review time in 8 hours or less. Doesn't matter if it says it'll be 8 days. Doesn't matter if says 1.8 months. In 8 hours, it will be review time. Maybe only 80 right now, but this time tomorrow it will be 800. If left for just 2 days, it will be the whole deck. Even if set manually to be reviewed in 15 days, it will not wait that long. You'll be reviewing it before you know it.

The curse of Anki.

jettyke: I drink coffee already. I also tend to forget to drink it on weekends. And sometimes I forget to drink it for weeks or months. I don't stop, I just forget to drink. It doesn't really make me study faster though, but I think I can understand spoken Japanese better on caffeine.

Reply #36 - 2011 May 12, 2:43 pm
overture2112 Member
From: New York Registered: 2010-05-16 Posts: 400

KMDES wrote:

nest0r wrote:

Every 8 hours?

Every 8 hours.

It's the curse of Anki. No matter what button I press. No matter what I set the settings at. No matter what, it's review time in 8 hours or less. Doesn't matter if it says it'll be 8 days. Doesn't matter if says 1.8 months. In 8 hours, it will be review time. Maybe only 80 right now, but this time tomorrow it will be 800. If left for just 2 days, it will be the whole deck. Even if set manually to be reviewed in 15 days, it will not wait that long. You'll be reviewing it before you know it.

The curse of Anki.

Obviously something is wrong with your Anki or deck settings. Or maybe your eases are totally messed up.  Reset cards, reinstall Anki, remake your decks, etc until you get a working SRS.

Reply #37 - 2011 May 12, 2:51 pm
KMDES Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-09-28 Posts: 306

Tried, tried and tried. I've uninstalled Anki, but apparently when it installs it installs into the deepest areas of your harddrive which doesn't unistall when you unistall it. It does this with every deck I've ever used, resetted or not. It even still does it after I reinstall a new OS. Somehow it must pull the settings from somewhere that I'm not seeing. Or maybe it's because I use 64bit OSes. I figured that hey, maybe it'll be fixed once it reaches version 1.0, but no such luck.

Now imagine, after taking 5 months to do RTK1 and adding something like 10-20 cards a day to have to review 1000+ reviews every time you open Anki? That's not my idea of fun.

Last edited by KMDES (2011 May 12, 2:53 pm)

Reply #38 - 2011 May 12, 2:57 pm
jettyke Member
From: 九州 Registered: 2008-04-07 Posts: 1194

Just ask it on anki forum.

Reply #39 - 2011 May 12, 2:59 pm
overture2112 Member
From: New York Registered: 2010-05-16 Posts: 400

KMDES wrote:

ta12121 wrote:

KMDES wrote:

Except SRSing is never fun. hmm

It's addicting for me. The thought about having so much knowledge for the long-term with only studying a few minutes per day is quite amazing. I've found that you need to spice up what you put into that thing. Rare/fun vocab/interesting and fun sentences. Something enjoyable for you keep to learning and learning. Or maybe it's only fun for me or at least interesting to do.

Sentences, words etc and only interesting if they have something interesting behind them.

This is true. That's why you should use subs2srs to study your favorite lines of your favorite characters in your favorite shows.

KMDES wrote:

And honestly who wants to read 'Hippos sweat pink sweat' in Japanese 20 times even though it was interesting the first time?

20 times???
I randomly grabbed a few hundred cards from a deck: I've only done 4-6 reps for them and the intervals ranged from 1.5months to 1.4years, with well over half being >6months.  I rarely mark as 4/easy, too.

Funny/badass/awesome lines stay that way even if you repeat them 6 times.

KMDES wrote:

Tried, tried and tried. I've uninstalled Anki, but apparently when it installs it installs into the deepest areas of your harddrive which doesn't unistall when you unistall it. It does this with every deck I've ever used, resetted or not. It even still does it after I reinstall a new OS. Somehow it must pull the settings from somewhere that I'm not seeing. Or maybe it's because I use 64bit OSes. I figured that hey, maybe it'll be fixed once it reaches version 1.0, but no such luck.

on win XP Anki stores stuff in:
* My Docs\Anki
# decks
* C:\Documents and Settings\userName\Application Data\.anki
# backups, plugins, preferences, config

on linux Anki stores stuff in:
* ~/.anki
# everything

Reply #40 - 2011 May 12, 3:03 pm
KMDES Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-09-28 Posts: 306

Even subs2srs is pretty boring. Sure, the lines are interesting when you watch the show, but you're not watching the show, you're studying the lines from a show, which in turn causes me to hate the show. Once you've had Anki show you the same opening lines 2+ times every day, it just doesn't become fun to watch anymore.

Also, Win7 Ultimate 64Bit.

Reply #41 - 2011 May 12, 3:10 pm
overture2112 Member
From: New York Registered: 2010-05-16 Posts: 400

KMDES wrote:

Even subs2srs is pretty boring. Sure, the lines are interesting when you watch the show, but you're not watching the show, you're studying the lines from a show, which in turn causes me to hate the show. Once you've had Anki show you the same opening lines 2+ times every day, it just doesn't become fun to watch anymore.

Also, Win7 Ultimate 64Bit.

Again, unless you're doing something wrong / have a broken SRS, you'll only see the same line a handful of times over the course of the first year, and intervals past that point are so long that they're basically never seen again.

Also, your subs2srs deck could have video clips on the question side and a lot of context sentences before and after the one being tested, so you're more or less watching the show in small pieces..

Reply #42 - 2011 May 12, 3:25 pm
KMDES Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-09-28 Posts: 306

Yeah, but how many times can you watch a show or something in a row before getting sick of it? I seriously find it as dissecting a show an It's 2 times, 3 if I'm pushing it in a year. Heck, it usualy takes me a decade for video games to getting around to actually playing them again. yikes

I seriously find it as dissecting a show and turning it from enjoyment into a chore. I shouldn't be forced to watch something over and over again just because. @_@

Reply #43 - 2011 May 12, 3:26 pm
nest0r Member
Registered: 2007-10-19 Posts: 5236 Website

@KMDES

I'm not sure why you keep saying ‘you’—the problems and responses you're describing are singular and extreme, so it should be ‘I’ or ‘me’, no? ^_^

Reply #44 - 2011 May 12, 3:28 pm
nest0r Member
Registered: 2007-10-19 Posts: 5236 Website

My strategy for subs2srs is just to sample 5-30 of my favourite/the most useful lines from many episodes/films.

At any rate, if you ever get your SRS working properly, perhaps you'll experience ‘flow’, which is great.

Last edited by nest0r (2011 May 12, 3:28 pm)

Reply #45 - 2011 May 12, 3:32 pm
KMDES Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-09-28 Posts: 306

nest0r wrote:

@KMDES

I'm not sure why you keep saying ‘you’—the problems and responses you're describing are singular and extreme, so it should be ‘I’ or ‘me’, no? ^_^

Just the way I say things. You/You'll is meant as a different kind of reference for myself, sort like a third person thing.

Also, I do experience 'flow' but it's when I play guitar or play video games, or reading. Not so much when I'll study.
Also, last time I tried to subs2srs a new show, it sure didn't turn out good ripping-wise. >_>

Reply #46 - 2011 May 12, 4:03 pm
nest0r Member
Registered: 2007-10-19 Posts: 5236 Website

nest0r finds that interesting. nest0r finds that flow in Anki is highly desirable, even when the information on cards is not particularly compelling, except insofar as it is information that is new to nest0r, which nest0r enjoys. nest0r finds something new and interesting with each spaced repetition of a card, especially when nest0r is reviewing nest0r's subs2srs cards. New layers are discovered and appreciated as nest0r's Japanese knowledge improves.

Perhaps KMDES can try a different spaced repetition program, suggests nest0r. Although Anki is the best, nest0r adds. Using Anki is why humans were created, and all who disagree with using the SRS is an infidel, jokes nest0r. nest0r smiles: ^_^.

Reply #47 - 2011 May 12, 4:30 pm
KMDES Member
From: Canada Registered: 2009-09-28 Posts: 306

"You'll get up in the morning, sure. You'll buy your Swiffer, eat some granola and stare at your lazy, Hanes-wearing boyfriend watching Jerry Springer on the couch."

An example I randomly pulled from google. Obviously the person is talking about themselves, as they probably don't mean every boyfriend is a 'Hanes-wearing boyfriend watching Jerry Springer on the couch'. So, I'm not the only one who does it! >: O

The way you did that last post sure reminds me of Index, KM as KM points out in a very obvious way that that is unusual.

But Anki is the one with all the neat features, premade decks and is free, KM as KM explains why a new program might not suit him.

I have tried out another program, the open source one, but I didn't find it very good, KM as KM says as he wonders if there's anything else out there besides Supermemo.

Reply #48 - 2011 May 12, 6:31 pm
zachandhobbes Member
From: California Registered: 2010-07-31 Posts: 592

I actually don't doubt the possibility of this. You'd just have to be in Japan, doing Japanese related work and force yourself to communicate.

My Jewish friend who I met in Japan as my guide lived there in the country as a homestay for 9 months and got fluent (well, functional, then she picked up all the city/urban speak quickly when she moved to the city).

Last edited by zachandhobbes (2011 May 12, 6:32 pm)

Reply #49 - 2011 May 12, 6:39 pm
bebio Member
From: Lisbon Registered: 2008-08-19 Posts: 94

jettyke wrote:

matto wrote:

That means, the Heisig method saved me between 1150-2050 hours and took around 1/10th of the time that other methods would need.

Could the same be done for learning a language such that you can learn it in just 10% of the time as traditional study methods?  If it were possible, how would setup a system?

No it didn't take you 10 times faster,

you only studied how to write and recognize them, but you know nothing about on yomi, kun yomi, all kinds of word compounds, reading kanji.

I agree with this. The original poster should not be so naive to assume that just because he partially memorized how to write 2046 kanji with just one meaning, that he has actually mastered Kanji. Once you arrive in Japan, you will quickly realize that you are still almost completely illiterate. The most common Kanji have tons of variations in meanings, depending on the context, there are many Kanji to be seen that fall outside of RTK1, and mastering the reading will keep you occupied for a long time.

Sure, do your best to simplify things, but don't get carried away...

Reply #50 - 2011 May 12, 7:10 pm
overture2112 Member
From: New York Registered: 2010-05-16 Posts: 400

KMDES wrote:

Yeah, but how many times can you watch a show or something in a row before getting sick of it? I seriously find it as dissecting a show an It's 2 times, 3 if I'm pushing it in a year. Heck, it usualy takes me a decade for video games to getting around to actually playing them again. yikes

I seriously find it as dissecting a show and turning it from enjoyment into a chore. I shouldn't be forced to watch something over and over again just because. @_@

If you really can't stand reading the same sentence 6 times in one year, you could add multiple examples that test the same things onto one fact, then when you do reviews simply cycle through them.  That way you would only see a sentence 1, although still test the focus point of a fact the handful of times you need before intervals are 1yr+.

In fact, it wouldn't be hard to make a plugin that hooked the card review display and automatically showed only the ImageN, ExpressionN, ReadingN etc field of the card where N = the card's reps count.

"Of course, MISAKA thinks you'd have to write that yourself since not many people share your problem", says MISAKA as MISAKA grins.