Your setup looks fine to me.

I don't think the story should be on the question side, that sort of defeats the purpose of active recall. Having the story on the answer side, on the other hand, is useful as a refresher if you've forgotten the kanji and need to fail the card. That doesn't mean you have to read the story if you already know it well, though. The stories are a means, not an end. Your goal isn't to remember the stories, it's to remember the kanji.

Bernkastel wrote:

Do you fail the card when you forget a primitive? If you take the example I posted above for example: If you forgot the "silver" primitive in root. Would you fail it? Thanks.

If you cannot write the whole kanji out from memory, then yes, I would fail it.

I did it the way Heisig did it in his book (I used paper flashcards and used them a few times in the beginning of the SRS): I wrote the story upside down on the keyword-side of the card. That way you don't read it right away, but it's there as an extra reminder. I don't know if Anki has an option to write upside down, though.

I don't know if you were joking about failing so much, but if you weren't: stop learning new cards right now and get the ones you've already done in your head better (for example with better stories).