RtK Doesn't mesh with the competitive soul in me

Index » RtK Volume 1

  • 1
 
zachandhobbes Member
From: California Registered: 2010-07-31 Posts: 592

I'm restarting RtK so we'll see how it goes, but here's a little rant.

I was going through RtK, oh, 3 or 4 months ago, at a very fast pace. 40-60 new cards a day.

and I was doing it! I wasn't half bad. I was kind of rushing the stories, my mistake, and emphasizing writing over imagining stories, but it was working for me.

Until I hit the longer chapters.

See, until about chapter 18ish (I forget exactly), chapters were about, anyhwere from 20-50 cards long.
Perfect for my rate of learning, because I did at max about 60 so I could do like 2-3 chapters, or 1 long chapter.

But then the 90 card chapters showed up, then like a 120 card chapter.

I could not sit with myself not finishing a chapter for some reason, I HAD to finish, even if it meant splitting it up among two or three LONG sessions in one day, I had to finish off the chapter by the end of the day.

that really killed me and I ended up getting to 999 (yes, I hated it so much at that point that I didn't even add the 1000th card) and quitting because of the burn and failing cards and everything falling on me as I realized the last 300 cards weren't really in my memory.

Why did Heisig feel like adding such long chapters was a good idea? It really killed me back then.

I've grown wiser since then but I think about what would have happened if I hadn't burned out and where I would be with my language learning now if I had continued from then. I would probably know all the Kanji up to 3000 and be in the midst of vocab and sentences...

oh well, can't change the past, only the future. but still, Heisig why?!

lernsky Member
From: Germany Registered: 2009-03-23 Posts: 54

There is no reason to follow the chapter structure. For example I added new cards at first following a book named KanjiABC. At some point I realized I would miss out most common kanji 'til the near end. So I continued adding kanji I *wanted* to learn. Also I refused to use certain radical meanings. There is no reason to not develop a good concept even further...

mafried Member
Registered: 2006-06-24 Posts: 766

Maybe because he grouped the kanji based on how they logically made sense, and without much respect to chapter size?

Anyway, I found that Heisig throws down quite a few challenges/traps along the way to test/train your adaptive self-learning skills. I found that the chapters slowly built up until BAM, there's a really long one. Then after that some are short, some are long; whatever the kanji needs. I think it's his way of saying "did you get the message? don't organize your studies around chapters."

Advertising (register and sign in to hide this)
JapanesePod101 Sponsor
 
Splatted Member
From: England Registered: 2010-10-02 Posts: 776

I tend to study in blocks of 11 because it makes nice numbers (I also stopped for a while at 999, but that was just because I liked it so much tongue). Maybe you should try living as a hippie for a while. It might help you mellow out.

nest0r Member
Registered: 2007-10-19 Posts: 5236 Website

You already admitted it's all you and your obsession with chapter completion, so you shouldn't be asking Heisig why, hehe. Why not do something like RTK Lite? Then go and fill in the rest later.

MountainDewGuy Member
From: Ohio Registered: 2011-01-29 Posts: 12

I guess he was just assuming his readers weren't autistic.

  • 1