How soon after studying do you add the kanji?

Index » RtK Volume 1

  • 1
 
Sevenhelmets Member
From: 新宿区 Registered: 2008-05-20 Posts: 38

I think my topic title says it all; after studying a character(s) from the book, how soon thereafter will you add it in RTK and review it? 

I'd presume most of us don't study the character, add it, and review immediately, because it would skew things a little (the character would still be very fresh in mind).  I normally add the character(s) after my study session, but don't do a review until a couple of days later.

I'd be interested to hear everyone else's thought on this, and what they tend to do....

alyks Member
From: Arizona Registered: 2008-05-31 Posts: 914 Website

I was wondering the same thing. Usually I study in groups of ten/twenty (after I think of a mnemonic image, I put it in anki) then study them in the order they were added, so the oldest kanji I studied 20 minutes ago are shown to me first.

The twenty minute mark is a good time to review again for me. Even that soon after I'll forget a couple.

QuackingShoe Member
From: USA Registered: 2008-04-19 Posts: 721

Immediately. I studied in groups of 10-15, at which point I'd immediately review those, then continue on. When I was done adding for the day, I'd review them all again as a batch (by removing and re-adding them to RevTK). I'd wait several hours, then review them all again. I might do that one more time, but it was pretty much left to the SRS after that point.

Advertising (register and sign in to hide this)
JapanesePod101 Sponsor
 
Sevenhelmets Member
From: 新宿区 Registered: 2008-05-20 Posts: 38

@ QuackingShoe

Out of curiosity, what is your retention rate like?  Of course there are many factors that will influence this, but I'm just wondering. 

When I leave my newly learnt Kanji for a couple of days, once I do finally review them for the first time my retention rate is normally in the 86-92% range.

alantin Member
From: Finland Registered: 2007-05-02 Posts: 346

Study --> add to the RvTK --> review the next day.

That's pretty much how I did it through the book although with the last quarter I added them first to anki and after reviewing them in anki for a couple of days, I added them to the site SRS.

Last edited by alantin (2008 August 05, 2:23 am)

canji Member
From: Portland OR Registered: 2008-07-25 Posts: 52

What would be a good retention rate for reviews? I get 75% or so. I figure if that means I am learning 1500 out of 2000 kanji well, then I can live with that as I resolve my issues with the other 500.

Also, for you 1000+ers, would you say kanji get more difficult as you go or is there nothing inheritantly more difficult about one in the 300s vs the 1300s or the 1800s?

Just wondering.

alyks Member
From: Arizona Registered: 2008-05-31 Posts: 914 Website

70%-90% is fine. That's the beauty of spaced repetition. No matter what, you're going to learn everything you put in eventually.
I would say that things stay at about the same difficulty as you progress. For me though, I'm having a hard time getting in my fifty a day because I just want this to be over with, and it's difficult to get motivated to do it.

Last edited by alyks (2008 August 05, 2:49 am)

FutureBlues Member
From: Japan Registered: 2008-06-04 Posts: 218

canji wrote:

What would be a good retention rate for reviews? I get 75% or so. I figure if that means I am learning 1500 out of 2000 kanji well, then I can live with that as I resolve my issues with the other 500.

Also, for you 1000+ers, would you say kanji get more difficult as you go or is there nothing inheritantly more difficult about one in the 300s vs the 1300s or the 1800s?

Just wondering.

From what I can tell, it gets a lot easier as you progress. I mean, sure, I forget maybe 10% of the kanji from stack 4 (I use anki, but stack 4 is 1 month+ interval) that pop up and occasionally even more than that, and I tend to fail maybe, 20-40% of my newly learned kanji on bad next days, but I'm at 1158 right now and I feel like I'm having a lot less trouble than I did around 600s or so.

I think the brain just gets used to learning things after a while and suddenly it's easier than ever to cram more and more into it. That's the way I feel now anyway.

QuackingShoe Member
From: USA Registered: 2008-04-19 Posts: 721

I usually have mid-80s-mid-90s% off newly learned kanji in those first few days, though I've of course fallen quite a bit further from time to time. It slides back up to 90-100% after that. I just added the last of the book on, er.... Tuesday? And I hit 96% on my most recent review. It is worth noting that I haven't gotten crazy-strict with my pass/fail, though, as of yet. I'd probably fail maybe an additional 4 or 5 out of 70 characters if I were to fail myself for small positioning errors and the like.

I only did it this way because I found I needed the immediate reinforcement to kick me off. Technically I could do the exact same thing without using this program, and I imagine most people do; that is, cover up the kanji and do some brief keyword to kanji work. I didn't, though, so I did it on here. And taking a break from studying to flashcard a block of 10-15 kanji refreshed me and gave me a small goal to shoot for on the way to the larger goal of finishing the lesson (goal of any given day was always a lesson).

About it getting easier... god, I wish that had been true for me. I absolutely reviled the last quarter of the book, but I think that was more about mindset than anything. I just really didn't want to have to do it anymore.

Last edited by QuackingShoe (2008 August 05, 3:39 am)

Reply #10 - 2008 August 05, 3:49 am
alantin Member
From: Finland Registered: 2007-05-02 Posts: 346

I think the difficulty stays about the same but there are portions with lots of obscure keywords that gave me a headache.

The last quarter was easy for me because I just couldn't wait to be done and I had a 4 or 5 full days to dedicate for the task! big_smile


About retention, I think 85 +-10 % is the good zone.
Below that means a really bad day and over gives the warm and fuzzy feeling. big_smile

Reply #11 - 2008 August 05, 6:24 am
PParisi Member
From: Columbus, GA Registered: 2007-07-19 Posts: 57

I have been adding them directly after I study them. I fail them all and then check everyone's stories to find the most helpful (if I can't make a good one up for myself).

Reply #12 - 2008 August 05, 2:15 pm
plumage Member
From: NYC Registered: 2008-05-27 Posts: 194

I also keep a graph-paper pad journal. I write each new character's keyword, and then either Heisig's story or a tweaked version (or my own), and then practice writing the character a few times. Once I've added as many kanji as I'm going to for that day, I add them into this site immediately, and review them sometime later in the day. On that initial review I allow myself to remind myself of the stories (but not the writing) if need be, to help the story to stick.

Reply #13 - 2008 August 05, 2:36 pm
QuackingShoe Member
From: USA Registered: 2008-04-19 Posts: 721

PParisi wrote:

I have been adding them directly after I study them. I fail them all and then check everyone's stories to find the most helpful (if I can't make a good one up for myself).

You may already be aware, but just to make sure, you don't actually need to fail a card to look at the stories. You can just go to the study page and search by kanji number. I typically went through the study section concurrently with my study from the book, rather than looking at the stories afterward.

Reply #14 - 2008 August 10, 10:52 am
zardoz73 Member
From: tokyo Registered: 2008-07-28 Posts: 13

I add immediately after studying and then immediately review.  I'm finding review just as important if not more important than adding new kanji.  I just passed the 500 mark, and am making mistakes with the reviews, but when I then go back AGAIN and review the ones I missed.  In the same sitting.  It helps a LOT to just keep hammering yourself with the ones you miss, even if it's just a missing stroke or two.

Reply #15 - 2008 August 18, 3:28 am
hknamida Member
From: Sweden Registered: 2007-08-16 Posts: 222 Website

I use Anki, and add the kanji (and sentences) immediately as I study them. Once I feel "done" with a card, I mark it as "difficult" (or whatever it's called in English), but not failed, to make it show up again after half a day or so. I then consider it learned, and start grading my performance accordingly.

Reply #16 - 2008 August 18, 12:46 pm
pazustep Member
From: Brazil Registered: 2007-04-09 Posts: 30 Website

I work on whole lessons, and add the kanji from the lesson right after I finish studying it. Then I'll go watch some dorama, movie... anything to clear my mind in the next hour or so. After that I come back and review the cards I added before.

I found this works pretty good. If I review the cards immediately, I'll sure remember almost everything, but my next review won't be so good. If I only review in the next day, retention will also be low.

One hour seems to be the magic point for me where I'll have forgotten the weaker stories, bust most stories are still fresh on my mind. This means I'll identify the stories that need some work not too long after I've studied them.

If I have the time, I'll repeat this cycle multiple times a day. There have been days where I added over 200 cards to my deck, but in cycles of 50 or so. I guess you have to experiment a little to find the ideal quantity and interval for you.

Reply #17 - 2008 August 20, 12:03 am
MoogleFan Member
Registered: 2008-04-19 Posts: 23 Website

I do about a lesson a day (unless it is particularly long, in which case I split it up arcross days), then add the kanji after I finish studying them. I don't test on them until the next day. I keep going until there are 20 kanji in my failed pile. Then I take awhile to study those. The next day, I test on the failed kanji. If I end up ith less than 20 in the pile, I resume progressing through the lessons.

  • 1