Language-Reading Method

Index » 喫茶店 (Koohii Lounge)

  • 1
 
Reply #1 - 2012 June 20, 6:43 pm
turvy Banned
From: Japan Registered: 2012-01-27 Posts: 430

I was reading about the L-R method to learn languages here and there and it seems there are a good number of people claiming good results. I looked at some wiki's and threads but couldn't find any good links to compiled parallel texts in L1 and L2 with audio.

Have you had any experience with this method to learn any language?.

Reply #2 - 2012 June 21, 8:15 am
SammyB Member
From: Sydney, Australia Registered: 2008-05-28 Posts: 337

Some members here have tried it. I think most agree that it doesn't work as well for Japanese as it does for non script based languages... I think others found that what they noticed was an increased familiarity with a particular text rather then overall improvement in language ability. But not having tried it myself, these are just things I recall other people mentioning.

Reply #3 - 2012 June 21, 9:25 am
eslang Member
Registered: 2012-01-27 Posts: 98

turvy wrote:

but couldn't find any good links to compiled parallel texts in L1 and L2 with audio

Seems like "buonaparte's audio and text links" ... there are lots of information and material in that thread.

I find it useful to listen and expose myself to different literature or articles but it won't be sufficient as the "only" method or "best" medium to learning any languages. 

Japanese is "considered a high-context language", maybe along with French and the Arabic languages from what I read in a book from Edward T. Hall, and if I may borrow from Richard Bowring words...

[...that a spoken language maintains a specific rhythm that relies on the presence of another person. Spoken language can be ungrammatical, relies on "eye contact, shared experiences and particular relationships [to] provide a background which allows speech to be at times fragmentary and even allusive". ]

Some schools of thought suggest "shadowing" when reading along with the audio material, but in some Asian languages (such as the Japanese, Thai, etc.) and  there are gender differences in the usage of the language, not to mention the nuances and subtle meanings.  It can be counter-productive in some cases if one simply uses it without proper understanding.

In a nutshell, I find that learning a language is more than just words, grammar, vocabularies... it also involves understanding the culture, custom, history and body or silent language which really forms the bulk of what comprises in a "language".

Advertising (register and sign in to hide this)
JapanesePod101 Sponsor
 
Reply #4 - 2012 June 21, 11:09 am
buonaparte Member
Registered: 2010-11-25 Posts: 796

eslang wrote:

In a nutshell, I find that learning a language is more than just words, grammar, vocabularies... it also involves understanding the culture, custom, history and body or silent language which really forms the bulk of what comprises in a "language".

It made me smile!
That's exactly why mLr came into being.

@turvy
it is called multilingual LISTENING-Reading, not Language-Reading Method.
You can find some stuff here:
http://users.bestweb.net/~siom/martian_mountain/

Happy-go-lucky Miss Hopper.

Last edited by buonaparte (2012 June 21, 11:10 am)

  • 1