Haych Wrote:Another reviewer just crossing the RtK finishline here. Its been quite a journey, I can tell you. From the very first moment I came across Remembering The Kanji about four months ago, I knew it was definitely a good resource. However, I never imagined it could take me all the way to 2042 with such high retension and virtually no reliance on visual memory. I only wish that I had found this site sooner! I didn't even know what a srs was when I started, and thus had the great idea of working my way through all the kanji at once.. making 2042 flashcards with absolutely NO review. The plan was to get my stories over with to refer back to, and reinforce their memory by seeing them in context. When I finished this horribly grudging task, all I had to show for it was 2042 mediocre stories, and a retension of maybe 400 of them. So, while working my way through my first set of reviews, I decided that it wasnt going to work, and began to look online for any sort of tool to help... Of course, when I found this site I was excited, but reasonably cynical. They have a nice setup.. but I just knew the next line would be something like "all yours for ONLY 5.99$ per month!!". Needless to say, that never came, and when I found out it was free, I signed up in an instant. I am sure today that I never would have made it without the site. Heisig's system is great and all.. but there is definitely such thing as a "good" and a "bad" story and without help (and none from Heisig's odd primitives and keywords either), you will likely end up with a whole lot of the latter like I did. But two months and a whole lot of srs'ing later and here I am. At the finish line once again, yet this time feeling like I might be able to recognise a few more than those of the first few lessons. So thank you everyone here for your great stories and encouragement. And to all those people who are still working their way through: Good luck and hang in there! If you keep a regular schedule you will be here in no time. Now for me, the fun has only begun. Once I get most of the stragglers up into deck 4, its onwards and upwards into sentence mining! (and hopefully knowing more the handful of phrases that I do now hehe)
Aaaaand crossing the finish line for a third time today! (the above is my post from the 2nd attempt)
But really that first time shouldn't count. I just made a bunch of paper flashcards with horrible stories and did pretty much no review. I think I might still have them somewhere... I should burn those.
But the second time was real. I was elated to be done. But after finishing, I just ignored my reviews after everything was in the last box. I figured exposure could keep them in my memory, and the reviews would just slow me down. Whaaaaat a mistake that was. After 3 years of very inconsistent study, and 1 year of flat-out resignation to pursue Japanese further, I had next to no retention of RTK. I could still sort of recognize words by their general shape, but I couldn't for the life of me remember a single keyword.
But I wasn't ready to give up the fight. This summer I picked up RTK 1 again to begin the long grind. As I made my way through, it was obvious that the keywords were truly lost from my memory. It was new to me once again, yet I managed to get some pretty good retention rates (usually over 80%), so I think some of the intuition at least was still there.
And now, around 3 Months later, using a standard 20 new cards/day, here I am once again. This might seem like the latest in a long proud line of failures, but I feel good about this one. I have a new weapon, and that is CONSISTENCY. I used to have periods of extreme zeal followed up by months of relapse. It was horrible. The fact that SRS need to be used EVERY DAY is something that never really sunk in for me in the last 4 years of study. I've come to realize now that it is not a burden. Doing it like this makes things EASIER for you in the end. Just look at me, I went through RTK 2 full times! High retention rates aside, that's much much more work than 1 time and the dwindling reviews of a 3 year span.
The lesson to learn here is basically DON'T do what I did, but if you find yourself in that position, go for it and do RTK again. It's not that bad. To be honest, I had a lot more fun this time around. It was almost nostalgic.
And now its right back into the fray for me. My kanji-to-meaning recognition is sharp as a tack and it feels great. Also, the nice thing about my method is that I was able to study other things in parallel. RTK didn't have to be my sole focus. I'm up to speed on grammar again too. As for my plans from here, RTK3 (but at a slower rate of 5-10/day), my quick and dirty vocab deck (my preferred method), and lots of exposure (hope to get my first japanese novel under my belt soon).
So good luck everyone! Its a great resource you've found here. With a little diligence, I believe we can assure that we WILL all get where we're aiming. Just don't let yourself lose sight of the goal.