Well, about 10 months after I started this little kanji journey, the first part has come to a happy conclusion. I've always been hard on myself, and was always aggravated at my lack of progress with
RtK. Yeah, 10 months is "slow" for many, and I wholeheartedly agree that
RtK is a task that can be done easily in a 3-5 month period. I just lost the thrill of learning kanji after awhile.
I started out at a decent pace of 20 per day, and had made it to 600-ish kanji in probably 2 months. After that, I really started to burn out and almost never put in new kanji, although I did keep up with reviews everyday. Ultimately, it took me nearly 7 months to make it to about 900 kanji. After that, I realized I had to pick it up if I was ever going to finish. I began a new habit of trying to do 50 a day... which only semi-worked. I ended up doing 50 one day, and maybe 50 throughout the rest of the week, lol. Ultimately though, I went rather fast (for me) through the last part of the book. I
finished kanji 900-2042 in just under 3 months, despite having many lazy setbacks.
My experiences with
RtK:
1. For me, keeping up with daily reviews was never much of an issue, and I didn't hate it per se. But adding new kanji after doing 40-100 reviews was just painful alot of days. Seeing as I work fulltime and go to school fulltime, plus like to spend a bit of my spare time running and playing games. And many times, after exhausting myself with reviews, new kanji just didn't even enter the picture.
2. Although I began losing interest in learning new kanji at about kanji #600, without a doubt from #1500 on it was an absolute struggle to even look at this review page anymore. I became discouraged with falling retention rates, not really due to bad memory, but moreso due to the confusion with keywords and such. For the last 600 kanji, there are so many keywords meaning basically the same thing, but I would always remember the stories for all of them, and mix up the keywords. Another problem I had was Heisig really seemed to run out of ideas with primitives, and alot of them became more complex. This really hurt my studying because I would remember stories without a problem and usually one part of a kanji, but would keep forgetting the central primitive.
In conclusion:
Looking back, I've come a long way. From someone who had a shaky grasp of hiragana/katakana and didn't even know what kanji were, I think I made good progress
RtK does work. It may not work for everyone, and (in some cases) it may lose its "fun" appeal, but if you stick with it, you will finish. I'd like to thank Fabrice, because I am almost certain had I not stumbled upon this site, I would have never
finished this book. I also used MANY of your stories! A big thank you to all of the other very creative stories, especially dingomick. You really were my savior for the last 300-400 kanji, haha. I added some of my own stories here and there; hopefully some of you guys still studying will find some of them useful
A final note:
To anyone who is still on their
RtK journey. keep at it! As many others have said, don't worry about speed and retention rates too much. Unless you are in a major rush to learn your Japanese, take it at a comfortable pace. I agree 100% that you should do your reviews everyday, but if you just don't feel like adding new kanji, then don't. I realized that if I tried to force-study when I had no intention of wanting to learn, I would fail miserably on my reviews the next day.
As for me, once my reviews lighten up a bit, it's off to Tae Kim and KO2001. I'm happy to be done, and proud. If I had told myself almost a year ago that I would voluntarily finish this book to the end, I would've laughed. I never thought I had it in me to finish. As a nice reward for finishing
RtK, my copy of the JP version of FF13 should be in in a few days, so I can celebrate with that, and have no idea what is going on in the game! It will be a great learning tool (one day) and an excellent motivational tool, to keep me going when I lose sight of why I really want to keep studying Japanese.
Good luck to all the current
RtK studiers, and see everyone in Japan! (one day)