Back

Anki 2.0 (alpha)

#1
Damien has said that he plans to release Anki 2.0 as Beta (Noted by resolve) at the beginning of half of March. So now would probably be a good time for people to grab the Alpha and test it out and see what they think. I say this because the entire interface for Anki has changed.
Note that the Alpha is not actually meant to study with just yet since its still undergoing changes and isn't quite ready for launch. There are still some kinks and features that need to be added in.

Download (Most recent of this post is Alpha6):
http://ankisrs.net/download/mirror/alpha/

Manual:
http://ankisrs.net/docs/dev/changes.html

---
My own thoughts.

Interface: Being someone that has gotten very use to Anki 1.x's interface and just the general style of windows layouts; Anki 2.0 is frustrating. There is no "Open deck.." any more really. You simply create a deck, download, or drop a deck in your deck folder and hit refresh and it pops up in the deck browser. Its pretty clear that Anki has been redesigned with touch screens in mind now. More accessible/simpler buttons and most of the operation has been moved to the main screen. You no longer work and modify your deck through hitting toolbar buttons or going through the menus. That aside, with a little bit of time it won't be too hard to get use to the layout, but it is annoying at first.

Terminology: Facts are now known as "Notes." This change is stupid I think since I always thought calling the primary thing facts and you create cards based on the "facts." But creating "notes" and making cards based on the notes, is just weird.
Models are now "Note Types."

Reviewing Options: Holy ***** options batman. I think a lot of people have longed for a more accessible way to modify the way their decks operate and now you can. Previously many of the options were locked away in the Advanced tab for your deck and was a bit intimidating to modify if you didn't really know what you were doing. Damien has gone and eliminated the Adv. tab and made efforts to present the options in a more digestible manner. You'll need to check out the manual to figure most stuff out.
I want to draw your attention to something new you can now tweak to affect the algorithm that we never could before. Forgetting index
In Anki 1.x the forgetting index was set in the background by the scheduler at 10%. This meant that out of all your mature cards, cards with intervals greater than 28 days, you were expected to forget about 10% of those cards (ie: 90% correct rate on mature cards). This 10% is known as the desired forgetting index. You can now change this to be whatever you want but Damien highly encourages you keep it at 10% since its a pretty solid number balancing learning and retention. There is however a new number you can also tweak: assumed forgetting index. Basically, if you are studying material that is quite difficult and you find that really you are forgetting 15% of the mature cards, then you can come in here and input 15% and it'll jigger the scheduler and try and pull your forgetting back toward 10%. Damien says this isn't automatic because it actually is pretty expensive to calculate so you need to modify it manually.

Studying: Failed and new cards are now put in a mode known as "Learning" where they have 3 buttons instead of 4; Again, Good, Easy. Cards in Learning now also have to go through "Steps." By default there are 2 steps where a card is spaced 1 minute after being answered followed by 10 minutes. You can add more steps in the Study Options sections (Its the text box that has "1 10" => 1 minute followed by 10 minute. 1 5 8 10 would 1min 5min 8min 10min; and so on). My biggest complaint about learning mode is it disrupts study flow. Regular review cards are given 4 buttons. So if for example during studying it switches back to "learning" you'll suddenly find you can't answer using "4." This is a small thing and I'm sure a plugin can be written to lump 4 with 3 in learning mode; nonetheless, annoying if you are trying to get through 400 cards in an hour.

Styling: Damien has really made styling the cards way more accesible. You now have direct access to the CSS sheet, which I don't believe you did in Anki 1.x (easily). Because of the minimalist interface design of 2.0, its shifted my card display up when maximized on my screen instead of being centered. I think with tweaking the style I can get it where I want.

AnkiWeb + Sharing: Damien has moved the Sharing download interface out of the program and appears to be moving it onto the website. He has mentioned he is still working on the interface for the web so its hard to say how it will work. All I know is you can no longer download shared decks or plugins from within Anki--at least at the moment.

Statistics: There is a new graph/stats window. The stats are more informative I feel and presented better but I have only one real complaint. You are stuck with 1 month, 1 year, or Deck life as graph display intervals. You can now export/save an image of the graphs though which is great. The most interesting graph IMO that we currently don't have in Anki 1.x is the "% correct based on time of the day" checking my Core6k deck out, apparently 8am-ish is my best time to review and it goes down hill during the day before picking back up a little bit in the evening.

Misc: The last thing that I have noted is that plugin writers will need to go back and update their plugins to support the new Anki. The "Japanese Support" plugin for instance doesn't work. It could be that they need to placed in the profile folder (a new feature) to work, but I don't see much mention on the manual if that is the case.

Decks: Forgot an important point. There is a new deck format layout. This means that all your decks will need to be migrated to the Anki 2.0 format. The new decks will be moved into the user profile folder and....actually it appears they are all placed into a giant SQLlite database now. (Anki 1.x decks are their own sqlite dbs). The old decks remain where they were, so if you want to rollback to Anki 1.x you can.

So, your own thoughts and reactions?
Edited: 2012-02-18, 1:38 am
Reply
#2
I agree, new naming convention is a really bad idea especially for such vague name like Note other than that I see a lot of effort goes into making things simpler which is a welcome change, Anki 1.x has one of the most scary and unfriendly interfaces out there and that doesn't help with popularity these days.

Having one folder for my decks is not a bad thing but it has to be consistent, I hate it how current Anki handles decks and backups. I cannot remember how many times I thought I'm reviewing a deck from my "proper" folder but in reality I was working on a deck hidden somewhere on my disk... Not having a default "GoTo" folder in 2012 is barbaric also people have SSDs now and doing bazzilion backups onto it is just BAD design.

I'm however against putting decks into one DB file, I've had my share of problems with corrupted files in the past which is understandable considering the number of devices I sync to but putting them into one file won't help my problem. Rather than backup one deck I'm currently working on I'll be forced to backup all of them, not to mention manual transfer between devices will also be burdened with unnecessary data. What if my deck becomes corrupted on my phone, will I have to re-download my whole database or just my deck?

Overall I'm gonna stick to 1.x till I'm forced to switch, but if I won't like it how the new version handles itself I might be tempted to switch from Anki entirely.
Reply
#3
Thanks for letting us know! I will check it out. I can keep the old version on my home computer and the alpha on my work computer, then it's easy to switch if needed.
Reply
May 16 - 30 : Pretty Big Deal: Save 31% on all Premium Subscriptions! - Sign up here
JapanesePod101
#4
I really hope we aren't forced to switch, but probably'll have to. I'm not too keen on the new Learning stage of cards. The main reason is because I don't understand what it means nor do I feel like reading about what it is... But I'm still against it.
Reply
#5
thurd Wrote:Having one folder for my decks is not a bad thing but it has to be consistent, I hate it how current Anki handles decks and backups. I cannot remember how many times I thought I'm reviewing a deck from my "proper" folder but in reality I was working on a deck hidden somewhere on my disk... Not having a default "GoTo" folder in 2012 is barbaric also people have SSDs now and doing bazzilion backups onto it is just BAD design.
I forgot to mention that you can now set the number of backups you want Anki to keep in 2.0.

blackbrich Wrote:I really hope we aren't forced to switch, but probably'll have to. I'm not too keen on the new Learning stage of cards. The main reason is because I don't understand what it means nor do I feel like reading about what it is... But I'm still against it.
You won't be "forced" to upgrade. This isn't a game or windows. Of course you won't get new features or bug fixes. Learning stage is no different from the way you currently see a new card in you deck. Difference is if you like to see a card multiple times before you increase the interval to hours or days, now you can set it to do that.
Reply
#6
vix86 Wrote:You won't be "forced" to upgrade. This isn't a game or windows. Of course you won't get new features or bug fixes. Learning stage is no different from the way you currently see a new card in you deck. Difference is if you like to see a card multiple times before you increase the interval to hours or days, now you can set it to do that.
I was definitely forced to upgrade to 1.2... If I wanted to continue being able to sync my deck online.

O-Ok, so if we won't be forced to do that small interval stuff, then all is well and I rescind my statement.
Reply
#7
On the flip side, I'm glad to see proper "learn mode" support. Now I can keep the regular intervals for cards and still review the new ones until they stick.
Reply
#8
To clarify, sometime in March is the target for it to enter a more widespread beta - a final release is not ready yet. For people interested in the development I suggest you check out the ankisrs-users forum, as most of the big changes have been discussed at length on there already.
Edited: 2012-02-18, 1:16 am
Reply
#9
Thanks I fixed it.
Reply
#10
vix86 Wrote:I forgot to mention that you can now set the number of backups you want Anki to keep in 2.0.
This has been available in anki for a while.

So in anki 2, will we have notepads instead of decks? =]

[edited] Let me slip in huge thanks to Resolve and our resident plugin wizards. I recently had to reinstall everything on my computer Sad and was reminded how much people have contributed. I don't know all names, but foosoft, thurd, cb4960, overture2112 and cangy - you guys are impressive and appreciated.
Edited: 2012-02-18, 8:29 am
Reply
#11
blackbrich Wrote:I really hope we aren't forced to switch, but probably'll have to. I'm not too keen on the new Learning stage of cards. The main reason is because I don't understand what it means nor do I feel like reading about what it is... But I'm still against it.
Considering all the trouble I went through to get a learn-mode like thing working in anki 1.2 (micro intervals + always refresh queues plugin + careful tweaks to button 1 multiplier / mature bonus works but still isn't perfect) I'm surprised why anyone would not want the extremely nice handling of new cards in 2.0.

[ Also you can effectively opt out of it by changing the default new card intervals to just a single 8/24hr interval ]
Reply
#12
Its had plugin support since start of beta. I've been trying to get my Maturing Cards to work right. Graph support is different now.
Reply
#13
I just downloaded Anki 2 here and I'm digging the new UI.
Reply
#14
Ahhh I don't like it. How do I go back???

Edit: Nvm lol. Did it.
Edited: 2012-07-30, 2:16 pm
Reply
#15
I think I'll stick to the gold ol' 1.somethingsomething I still have... :p
Reply
#16
I really like it. I like that all cards exist in the same collection, and you can divvy them into decks based on that. It allows me to have this growing, searchable database of words/sentences from subs2srs imports that I can selectively yank into my active deck. Also like Filtered Decks and all the learning improvements.
Reply
#17
How can I review only recognition cards? I am using the Chinese Support plugin which generates Recall/Recognition cards. But I just want to review Recognition. In fact how can I delete Recall cards altogether.
Edited: 2012-07-30, 7:56 pm
Reply
#18
Please post Anki questions on the Anki forum.
Reply
#19
It was just a simple question, didn't know it was a sin to ask anything about Anki anywhere but the Anki forums…
Edited: 2012-07-31, 7:51 am
Reply
#20
turvy Wrote:It was just a simple question, didn't know it was a sin to ask anything about Anki anywhere but the Anki forums…
(BROKEN LINK) It's pretty common knowledge.
Reply
#21
turvy Wrote:It was just a simple question, didn't know it was a sin to ask anything about Anki anywhere but the Anki forums…
if you're using anki 2 beta, go to browser, type in card:Recall, ctrl+A, click suspend.

Now you have suspended all recall cards.
Reply
#22
My only gripe is that customizing the layout (fonts, sizes, colors) is done purely through html, and not the interface Anki1 had. Customization is really important to me but I don't know anything about coding.

Oh well, there's a simple guide for it and it might be improved in the future though?
Reply
#23
financialwar Wrote:
turvy Wrote:It was just a simple question, didn't know it was a sin to ask anything about Anki anywhere but the Anki forums…
if you're using anki 2 beta, go to browser, type in card:Recall, ctrl+A, click suspend.

Now you have suspended all recall cards.
Uh you don't have to suspend the cards to review them now. With Anki 2.0 you can now create filter decks to let you review specific filtered stuff.

http://ankisrs.net/docs/dev/changes.html...p_cramming

@TwoMore: Yes, the fact that you have to customize stuff now to get it back to how you use to be reviewing; kind of annoys me. It took me quite a while to figure out how to get it set up so stuff was centered on the screen.
Reply