aphasiac Wrote:At the risk of pointing out the obvious..1) Dating and Prostitution are two separate issues. These older men aren't looking to date these young girls, they are looking to screw them.
From the girl's perspective - who says it's "fun"? once money is involved there will be pressure to do things she is not comfortable with, with a man she's not in love with and possibly not even attracted to. It has the potential to screw her up emotionally for the rest of her life (not to mention she'll be stigmatised if she's caught). Yes I'm sure some girls enjoy it, just like some adult escorts enjoy their jobs, but there's huge potential for emotional harm so why risk it?
From the man's perspective - why on earth would a salaryman aged 30-50 want to date a girl in her early teens? What do they have in common? What will they talk about? Do you think this is going to be a healthy relationship with loving respectful sex? Even if they do fall in love, will the relationship last long term. Again, too much risk of damage to the girl.
As you and Icecream pointed out, young died out centuries ago in all civilised countries; It is hugely embarrassing for Japan to allow this to go on in this day and age.
2) Prostitution just like anything else is an exchange of money for services, sex in this case. Just like any kind of "service contract" the rules can be set down pretty easily. "Condom, no bruising, light biting, don't draw blood, etc etc." Can stuff go horribly wrong? Can pressure be put on to do more? Ya. But this applies likewise in so much else. Everything you stated here could just as easily affect someone that's 25 or 30. If during the act someone gets too rough and hits the girl as "part of the fun" and it actually hurts her, then you can press charges on assault. Is this the fault of prostitution? If someones wife gets hit during sex and hurt, is this the fault of marriage? See how absurd it is? All the issues people tend to list for "why we shouldn't have prostitution." can be solved through applying other laws already on the book.
I'll say it again. The only likely valid argument against underage prostitution might be the point about "emotional fragility." But I'm exceptionally skeptical that this would apply to people that are considered high schoolers, which are probably the largest group participating in Enjo-kosai in the "illegal" sphere.
3) Lastly, Japan isn't ignoring the issue. About each month I hear about guys being arrested for sex with minors in Japan. So they are defiantly pursuing the matter. They aren't just turning a blind eye. And the right conservative political sector of Japan is coming down harder and harder on your usual "family values" thing. Look at the hypocrite Tokyo Governor Ishihara.


.)