bodhisamaya Wrote:Please don't study for exams. It doesn't work. Japan accounts for 46% of all worldwide TOEIC applicants, yet ranks 24th out of 26 countries in test results. The cause: a culture of studying for exams. By studying for exams rather than for actually learning the language, you fail in both quests.
Didn't read the thread, just saw this post and noticed it was way off.
The reason Japan scores low on TOEIC is that so many people take the test. In most other countries people only take TOEIC when they want to work in an English environment or if they specifically take it for a job. Most of the people who take it in most countries are at least of college age, and are serious about working in an English environment.
In Japan, on the other hand, a lot of people take the TOEIC test for no reason at all. People take the TOEIC test for the same reason many of take the JLPT--just to measure English ability for fun. Old ladies love it. Even high school kids take the test for no reason. Of course, you also get people who want to work abroad and stuff like that, buy the reasons vary a lot more in Japan. But, generally, in Japan people just like to pass tests because of the test culture.
The result is that you have a huge pool of people taking the TOEIC exam in Japan, and many that are younger or not as serious as those taking the exam in foreign countries. The result? The average score in Japan is lower. But it's just because the pool of people taking the test is so big. More people means more mediocrity and lower test results, when compared to just a small number of more committed people.
So, actually, the fact that the Japanese score low on TOEIC has nothing to do with whether or not studying for exams makes you better or worse at the subject. It's completely unrelated.
(I met a professor in Japan who wrote an article about this and how it's used incorrectly to show the failure of English education in Japan. It's just bad statistics)
Edited: 2011-04-10, 8:13 am