Greetings all,
I've been studying Heisig off and on for quite some time. I've actually gotten pretty far along recently until I started working with a tutor. When I started working with my tutor, my tutor insisted that we start Minna No Nihongo I (I was actually about to start book II) from the beginning learning all the kanji compounds for the vocabulary. While I really applaud my tutor for going where no other previous teacher has dared (insisting learning kanji prior to those introduced in the book) I wonder what this will do to my Heisig system.
Previously, my Heisig kanji was essentially seperate from class kanji due to the fact I was at about 1500 and we were learning very, very basic kanji (???, etc). Therefore, there was no overlap or conflict.
Personally, I think that I should continue and try to quickly finish up Heisig, then there shouldn't be an issue. What do you think? Any comments welcome
I've been studying Heisig off and on for quite some time. I've actually gotten pretty far along recently until I started working with a tutor. When I started working with my tutor, my tutor insisted that we start Minna No Nihongo I (I was actually about to start book II) from the beginning learning all the kanji compounds for the vocabulary. While I really applaud my tutor for going where no other previous teacher has dared (insisting learning kanji prior to those introduced in the book) I wonder what this will do to my Heisig system.
Previously, my Heisig kanji was essentially seperate from class kanji due to the fact I was at about 1500 and we were learning very, very basic kanji (???, etc). Therefore, there was no overlap or conflict.
Personally, I think that I should continue and try to quickly finish up Heisig, then there shouldn't be an issue. What do you think? Any comments welcome
