Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 82
Thanks:
0
Has anyone else noticed that when white 白 gets added to another primitive, the resultant meaning is often something like a "better" version?
For example, white added to one 一 is hundred 百。
White added to person 人 is chief 伯。
White added to king 王 is emporer 皇。
White added to boat 舟 is liner 舶。
Doing a brief search, I find a few little tidbits claiming that the Chinese associated white with things like death or purity, but I feel like there must be a deeper story to it. I wonder if there are any good books out there that might discuss topics like this?
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 323
Thanks:
0
hmm.. I've always associated white with death... Ghosts, for example, are always portrayed wearing white garments.
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 3,944
Thanks:
11
Don't forget that in many kanji, those elements are just representing a sound and not the meaning of the stand alone character.
According to Kanjigen:
In 百, 白 is used purely for sound and has nothing to do with white.
In 伯, the same.
In 皇, the top part was originally 自, not 白, which originally had the meaning of はじまる (in this case, "first" as in "top")
In 舶, they say that 白 is for sound but don't mention why that element was chosen.
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 252
Thanks:
2
My interpretation (thus "seems to be") of the bronze script characters. The top of 皇 is a circle with spikes, similar to 自, except that 自 has the two lines in the center (like it's modern form) while 皇 was written with an empty or dotted circle. Admittedly, I'm no expert on ancient Chinese, so I could be wrong.
Or, more prosaically, I took a look at the old forms, pulled something out of my ass, and hedged it.
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 3,944
Thanks:
11
Oh, OK. I just wondered because there are conflicting accounts of character etymology since a lot of it is so uncertain. I typically just blindly trust Kanjigen because I don't know anything about interpreting the evidence myself.
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 4,582
Thanks:
0
Ugh my head hurts. Changed my mind, kanji's way too complicated.
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 885
Thanks:
0
Nice thought but yeah wrong unfortunately. The individual character itself, unless a pictograph or a very very straightforward ideograph has no chance of any of the sort of thing you mentioned. If you think something is out of the ordinary then think otherwise because although it may seem so, it is purely coincidental and you are thinking too much (which is a good thing!)
Regardless of that fact, at least it helps out with your stories. So while factually it may be wrong, there is no need to stop thinking about it completely.
Well done
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 672
Thanks:
0
Speaking of white- I walked by a Japanese wedding in Tenjin today- I asked my girlfriend why they wear those white "egg" looking hats. She had no idea besides that it was Japanese custom. I thought perhaps there is some symbolism behind the design- anyone know?
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 52
Thanks:
0
I heard those white hoods have something to do with hiding the brides "horns". I'm sure someone else can give a better explanation.
Edited: 2009-12-12, 2:26 am