shirokuro Wrote:As a gay male, I feel like I should offer my perspective on this issue.
This is a matter of being considerate. This is a forum. You don't know everyone on here. There's a diverse readership, and I think that more important than being "PC" is being sensitive. As iAurora said, there's no need to use "gay" in a negative way. It's completely unnecessary, and it can be very hurtful.
My stomach sinks when I read words like "gay" being used in this way. The negative connotations, to me, are through association with people like me who don't belong to the heterosexual majority. In my view, you are actively perpetuating homophobia and contempt for the queer community at large by using words like "gay" in such a way.
Honestly, it should be enough to know that you are offending people on here when you use words like "gay" in this way. It's really not something I want to read on here. Please don't use it. Thank you.
I am sorry that you must feel this way, and I am sorry that there are people in this world who are so bothered and intimidated by another person's sexuality that they feel to the need to oppress that person. But I also hope that you can understand that the vast majority of people who use the word "gay" to refer to something bad in no way are simultaneously thinking of that particular object or situation as similar to homosexuality. Even though "gay" is used to refer to "homosexual" about as much as it is used to refer to something negative, that does not mean that most people see the two words as in any way connected. Certainly, although I know the original meanings of many insults, I don't think of that minority group when I use or see them. As an example, my sister limps when she walks due to complications at birth and, while I would never call her a "gimp", I've certainly used the word in the past for comedic effect. But I love my sister, do not think any less of her, and actually think her limp is rather adorable. So, my use of the word "gimp" does not mean that I have anything against people who limp or have a lame leg; it's just a way of expressing myself in a way that I feel, at the time, is the most effective.
I am not saying that you don't have the full right to feel the way you feel, because you do. If the use of the word makes you feel uncomfortable or even unhappy, then you have every right to ask that person not to use that word in a derogatory way. But although you may see it as an affront to who you are, the person using the term probably is not putting as much thought into it. That's not to say your feelings aren't valid, just that, as hard as it may be, it's probably better not to read too much into what a person says, no matter how offensive it may seem. Certainly, in the majority of cases, that person is not trying to make you feel bad, and would feel horrible if they knew that was the situation.
kazelee Wrote:mirina Wrote:What negative stereotypes regarding homosexual people play into the colloquial usage of the word "gay"?
Gay - Homosexuality is distasteful, disgraceful, shameful, not in accord, an abomination, not right, a plague, the result of a weak and disconcerted mind, weird, unnatural, unwanted, wrong... just wrong, weird, very very bad, disgusting...
Dude, you're gay. That's so gay. How gay is that?
I've never used the word "gay" to express any of that whatsoever. My aforementioned video game is not, for example, an actual abomination.
kazelee Wrote:I was gonna use some outlandishly offensive sentence as a rebuttal here, but they're be no coming no coming back from that.
It would probably make things more interesting if you did.
kazelee Wrote:Instead I'll just politely suggests that you take some of this information into consideration and try to understand that you are responsible for the word you use and how you choose to use them as well as understanding that words have multiple meanings and that what one says in not often what is communicated. If you weren't partly aware of this already, your vernacular would be something totally different from what it is now, I believe.
To be honest, you are, in a way, expressing a part of my point, although in a roundabout way.
We, as in all of the members of this forum, experience things differently. While I can try to express myself as appropriately as possible, I can't control how that person interprets what I am saying. Take, for example, the other thread that spawned this one. I don't recall who it was, or precisely what was said, but someone made a joke about calling things "gay", and another person thought that individual was serious and asked them to stop using that word, even though the person who made the joke was speaking facetiously. So, although both posters shared the same opinions, the other person misinterpreted what the original poster was expressing, and was offended by that poster's comment (even though they agreed!). That is what I mean when I say, I'm not responsible for another person's subjective observation. There is absolutely no way whatsoever that I can control what another person's sees.
Quote:I think it's amusing (and kind of sad) that an actual homosexual person responded to say they personally didn't like the use of gay and wished people would stop using it on the forum, and all the anti-PCers just ignored that and kept on arguing about how they're not offending or insulting anyone by using it.
No one said that.
Quote:You can't avoid responsibility for the words you use.
I am responsible for the words I use. I am not responsible for how someone interprets them. Read my above example. You will never, in your life, be able to, in every situation, accurately guess how someone will interpret what you are saying. Even if you try your best to be as unoffensive as possible, at some point, you will offend someone.
Edited: 2010-02-05, 6:55 pm