With a goal of transparency and positive resolution I have sent this email to Joseph at White Rabbit Press.
If you're looking for WRP flashcard decks, please email them with similar or better suggestions to support more positive solutions that benefit everyone. (
WRP forum)
-------
Re: Piracy
-------
Hi Joseph,
The link you have provided points to an entire topic rather than a single post. I coudln't see a particular post pointing to unauthorized use of White Rabbit Press material. They do provide links to flashcard sets on smartfm or other website, for KO2001 and CosCom material (both of which I have not received complaints from, and they are certainly aware of these lists on smartfm).
If you see a particular post containing download links or specific instructions to make illegal copies of copyrighted WRP material, then I am happy to moderate those with a clear message for the users. Otherwise I can not moderate such topics without giving a good reason to the community members.
With all that said I have posted a notice here:
http://forum.koohii.com/showthread.php?p...7#pid88177
The RevTK community forums do not condone piracy, that is true. It's in the forum guidelines:
http://forum.koohii.com/showthread.php?tid=180
However as a community administrator I have to walk a fine line between maintaining a good direction for the forum, and taking some distance to allow people to self regulate. Users will most respect you and be most cooperative when they understand the reasons why posts are edited or why certain rules are in place, which is what I have tried to do with those guidelines.
Part of the guidelines is that I may edit out some links, but the discussion of such materials is usually tolerated. You have to tolerate that flashcard software users are free to create the decks that they want, for their own use. You can try to control the dsitribution but it will always be a vain effort. If they dont post on this board they will post somewhere else.
As for the proactive suggestions I mentioned in the forum post...
If you want to protect the particular association of kanji information displayed on the WRP flashcards, which is copyrightable, I would suggest as the most proactive way to actually create your own Anki decks and official smartfm decks for example. Just like the Monthy Pythons eventually created the official YouTube channel, in the same spirit. That way, since you are copyright holder, you have even the right to sell these, or you may use these decks as more promotion.
Please take this suggestion with a grain of salt. Obviously I am not a seller myself, but I have come a long way with my own site, and realized how the things are changing out there. There's simply no way that you will stop people from sharing flashcard sets based on WRP if they want to, and you will simply spend more and more energy emailing various forums, sites and so on, to get such links removed. Plus the time spent googling and setting up alerts to find them. Perhaps you find theat the market is small enough to warrant the effort and to be able to control the spread, I would argue that if you create your own official decks you may easily sell them at a low price and get both my (as the administrator who has to moderate offending links), and the user's cooperation, respects and support.
This was meant with the best intentions, so please forgive me if it came accross in any way as arrogant, it was not my intention.
All the best,
-Fabrice
-------
PS: I was actually in talks with WRP about advertising. So paradoxically this led me to this more in depth reply. The reason is that I need to be congruous between advertising and community moderation. I don't want that an advertising or affiliate partnership to become some sort of implicit agreement for controlling forum discussions. For example I would not moderate people who would constructively criticize KanjiPoster, or JapanesePod101. Let's be clear: the forum guidelines stay, we do not condone piracy. So this is more of a principle.