Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 287
Thanks:
0
Hi from New York City!
While watching the show K-ON, one of the female characters has the name 平沢 憂 Hirasawa Ui.
But no matter where I look, whether it be Wiktionary, RikaiChan, EDICT, or other sources, the kanji 憂 "ui" is associated with melancholy, grieving, anxiety, and sadness. I've read that Japanese names can fluctuate greatly with trends and times and that sometimes auditory aesthetics render original etymology nearly irrelevant.
Still, it puzzles me why anyone would name their child with this kanji. Especially when certain Japanese place value in stroke count of a name or other linguistic traditions. Why not 有為 or 羽衣? I understand there are many rules and lists and customs that those suggestions ignore (Hagoromo), but the reasoning behind naming a girl 憂 truly escapes me. Please help.
拙者に説明して下さい。宜しくお願い申し上げます。
Edited: 2009-07-08, 7:10 pm
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 1,061
Thanks:
0
けいおん! is an anime... i'm not sure if that is a real name to begin with... could be a made up 1 right?
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 163
Thanks:
0
FWIW - I have the rikaichan plugin with the names database, and 憂 shows up with a name reading of うい.
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 287
Thanks:
0
Thanks for the replies 皆さん。
Yes, K-ON is the new Haruhi, especially since KADOKAWA loves trolling its fans, but none of the other characters' names are unorthodox in any way.
Nor are unconventional names common in these slice of life comedies about "ordinary" but "intriguing" characters. Like "山田" or "Smith" these names are supposed to be 普通 ordinary。
Take for example the real-life model, 前田憂佳 Maeda Yuuka, her name has the 憂 in it as well.
Is there no stigma attached to the word as a name?
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 1,061
Thanks:
0
my Japanese wife says "i don't know why" -_- maybe they are trying to be Emo or something...
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 195
Thanks:
3
Maybe there's an additional connotation of, like, concern the hardships of others, a sort of sympathetic pain? 憂国 (patriotism) isn't so depressing, but still has that element of sort of supportive worry.
Or...maybe they just think the character looks pretty. It is pretty close to 愛 in appearance, maybe there's some sort of implied connection based on that.
Just guessing, really. It certainly doesn't seem like an optimistic character choice overall though.
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 3,851
Thanks:
0
It used to be the norm to give your child an awful name until they become adults so that spirits or whatever avoid them. There was a girl in Genji Monogatari named "Dog girl".
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 287
Thanks:
0
So is this societal amnesia with regards to a pre-modern custom? I'm supposing that the child changes their name to something less negative when they mature? But I haven't read of any custom or pattern of re-naming children once they come of age in Japan.
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 3,851
Thanks:
0
It used to be common, but probably not during the life of anyone alive today.
You still change your name when you die though.
Of course that might not be the reason (to give it a classical feeling) she has a depressing name. It seems in many anime there is always the tragic character, so maybe it really is just for emo's sake.
Edited: 2009-07-09, 2:03 am
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 12
Thanks:
0
Well, I looked the cast up, and it seems that the first names of all the girls in the show, including side characters, are a single kanji long. It looks like an intentional design decision, and as for Ui, they probably tried to choose a common name one character long which also pairs with her sister's name 唯 (Yui)