Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,708
Thanks:
13
先生に許可をもらって早退しました。
if this were
先生から許可をもらって早退しました。
Would it significantly change the meaning (or make it incorrect)?
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 3,944
Thanks:
11
No, those are the same. I've seen the claim that に is more common.
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 748
Thanks:
0
Tomehane Ep.1
"Evil" girl says to a group:
それに比べて 何? あんたたちんとこ。
translated as:
So what YOU you have to compare it with?
In other instance, same situation:
あんたんとこ よく こんな 小学生みたいな作品 出すよね。
translated:
You guys really are exhibiting stuff that's work like that of an elementary schooler!
My question is about that んとこ, is it just some sort of derogatory slang or is it something else? Couldn't find anything on concrete on JDIC, Google, goo or even DoIJG.
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 485
Thanks:
0
Is it just slang for のところ?
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 285
Thanks:
22
It's an abbreviation of のところ.
edit: beaten to it!
Edited: 2012-02-21, 3:52 pm
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,708
Thanks:
13
師走(しわす)
How often have people encountered this word? A google search only finds me about 12M hits which is not a lot. EDICT says its an obsolete word, yet its in the core6k. I'm considering suspending it since it seems so obscure and the character semantic meaning makes no sense for the meaning (December). I don't want it polluting my stats and wasting my time.
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 3,944
Thanks:
11
I've only seen it in Genji; these month names occur occasionally in modern Japanese but I've never seen しわす in modern.
For instance, from Genji:
うち泣きつつ過ぐすほどに、師走にもなりぬ。 (modern: 泣き泣き過ごしているままに、師走になった。)
師走の二十日余りのほどに、中宮まかでさせたまひて (modern: 師走の二十日ごろ、秋好中宮が(奈良に)いらっしゃいまして)
Seems out of place in a "core 6000" deck.
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 399
I get the idea but I just can't come up with an English translation that works…
この本を読む皆さんへ夢のために頑張り続ける。
1) My dream is that everyone works hard to read this book.
2) That everyone keeps working hard to read this book is my dream.
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 3,944
Thanks:
11
To everyone who reads this book -- continue to work hard for (towards) your dreams.
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,668
Thanks:
0
i think it's:
To everyone who reads this book, i'll keep fighting to fulfill (my) dreams.
この本を読む皆さん へ 夢のため 頑張り続ける
everyone who reads this book to for (my) dreams (I)'ll keep 頑張るing.
edit: Yudan is probably correct, as my and I was an assumption on my part.
Edited: 2012-02-22, 6:42 am
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 399
@nadiatims Isn't that such an odd thing to say? fighting for my dreams in the context of a small blurb of introductory text to a 1st grade students book.
The whole thing is:
この本を読む皆さんへ夢のために頑張り続ける。それまで無かったものを作り出す。本当にいた、すごい人の、わくわくどきどきするお話を読みましょう。
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 533
Thanks:
1
I have read that december is 師走 because it's the last month before the new year -- hence all the priests are running around trying to make preparations.
(I agree that the old names of the months are an obscure thing very few people really need to know.)
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,668
Thanks:
0
@turvy
yeah it's an odd thing to say I guess. But sometimes people say odd things. If you don't post the context it's kind of ambiguous who the subject is in that sentence. Now you post the context, I'm pretty sure both the first sentences are actually talking about the character of the book.
この本を読む皆さんへ夢のために頑張り続ける。それまで無かったものを作り出す。本当にいた、すごい人の、わくわくどきどきするお話を読みましょう。
to everyone who reads this book, (a person who) continues to fight for (their) dream. (a person who) creates/does something never before done/created. Let's read n exciting and thrilling story about an amazing person who was really there (in the place, at ground zero or whatever).
More elegantly
Let's read an exciting and thrilling story about an amazing person who was really there, and who continues to fight for their dreams and create/do something new.
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 399
Mmm, I think I get it now. What about:
この本を読む皆さんへ
To those reading this book
(To the readers of this book)
夢のために頑張り続ける。それまで無かったものを作り出す。To keep fighting for your dreams until you can do what hasn't been done before.
本当にいた、すごい人の、わくわくどきどきするお話を読みましょう。
Let's read a story of the amazing people that did this.
(Of the really amazing people who accomplished this, let's read their story.)
Edited: 2012-02-22, 8:22 am
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 533
Thanks:
1
No, I agree with nadiatims's interpretation where 夢のために頑張り続ける and それまで無かったものを作り出す are clauses that modify 本当にいた、すごい人. It's unusual for a clause to keep going past the sentence boundary, but it's more unusual for a present-tense sentence to be an imperative unless it's followed by んだ or something like that.
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 399
It's from this book
http://www.amazon.co.jp/gp/product/40520...00_details
A compilation of mini biographies about these remarkable people the author talks about in the blurb.
What I wrote: "To keep fighting for your dreams until you can do what hasn't been done before."
By "your dreams" I mean that impersonally, "one's dreams" and not the reader's dreams, the subject/s are the characters of the different stories. I agree with nadiatims' interpretation as well.
Edited: 2012-02-22, 8:30 am
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 3,944
Thanks:
11
Is the punctuation in the original or did you add it (it's very odd for that へ to just continue into the next word without a line break, comma, or period)? I like nadiatims' second post the best as far as the meaning.
To me it makes more sense as:
この本を読む皆さんへ
夢のために頑張り続ける、それまで無かったものを作り出す、本当にいた、すごい人の、わくわくどきどきするお話を読みましょう。
But even if it's not like that the periods may be for emphasis rather than end-of-sentence...punctuation isn't always consistent in Japanese.
Edited: 2012-02-22, 8:31 am
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 399
I haven't edited any of the original posts. If I were to translate it now, I would say:
この本を読む皆さんへ
To the readers:
夢のために頑張り続ける。それまで無かったものを作り出す。
本当にいた、すごい人の、わくわくどきどきするお話を読みましょう。
Let's read a story about really amazing people that kept fighting for their dreams until the did what was never done before.
EDIT: I see what you mean. In the book there is a line break after へ. So it should have been obvious to the experienced reader, (not me).
Edited: 2012-02-22, 8:35 am