Back

RTK while taking Japanese class - any experiences?

#1
Has anyone tried completing RTK while taking a Japanese class?

Heisig does warns us that combining RTK with the traditional study of kanji has an adverse effect on the learning process. I was hoping that I'd be able to complete RTK1 by the end of December. In class we study around 20 kanji every two weeks.

Before I get myself into RTK, does anyone advise against it?
Edited: 2008-10-13, 11:12 am
Reply
#2
My opinion is: it's not going to hurt you.

I find that studying them alongside in the traditional manner whilst learning grammar, vocabulary etc completely solidifies it in my head for me.
Reply
#3
Personally, I stopped training kanji in a traditional sense when I started doing Heisig. I don't think it's counter-productive, but I do think it's a waste of time. Since you have classes and can't skip the traditional ones, do them together.
Reply
May 16 - 30 : Pretty Big Deal: Save 31% on all Premium Subscriptions! - Sign up here
JapanesePod101
#4
The only danger is that you may become so enamored with doing Heisig that you neglect your other classwork - this has happened to me while studying for the JLPT2; I have picked up Kanji at the cost of studying grammar.

But everyone reacts differently. Do it alongside your classes, pay attention to what happens, and adjust accordingly.
Reply
#5
I did RtK while taking classes, and I can't say I've had any problems because of it.
Reply
#6
That's good to hear. I'll be starting RTK, then.
Reply
#7
Being able to associate a RTK kanji with a vocab word you already know really helps you learn both the kanji and the underlying vocab word. Some kanji which were difficult to get to stick, stuck almost instantly when I associated them with a word in my vocab SRS. At that point I didn't even need the story (which stories were never working to get those few kanji to stick anyway).
Reply