Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 57
Thanks:
0
I guess it's fine if you're only making notes for yourself. It's mostly unreadable for me though.
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 1,093
Thanks:
54
Mostly I just try to draw each stroke a bit faster but still correctly. There are fixed places where I'll connect my strokes - the middle two strokes of 目 and the bottom two strokes of 日, for example. I try not to connect any strokes I haven't seen connected in native handwriting (grass script doesn't count for that, of course.)
I might worry more about shortcuts if I were handwriting text, but I almost exclusively write characters as practice. Almost all of my actual writing of text is typed. If I'm writing for practice I don't want to be sloppy or incorrect, because then it's not very good practice.
Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 109
Thanks:
0
Thanks, kushiote and REH94, for the 行書 sites and the kanji dictionary. I have looked through them and taken notes of shortcuts I am going to try and learn.
Regarding the usage, I mostly am interested in this as a way of shortening my review times a little bit. I like to write each kanji out on paper, but as of until now I struggled to find good ways to write the radicals fast - as the best way would be to do it how natives do.
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,144
Thanks:
0
I think getting 楷書 down properly should come first... if you're struggling with regular character forms (which by the sounds of it is the case - otherwise you shouldn't have trouble writing at a decent pace), then any attempts at other forms aren't going to be particularly pretty.
Just keep writing with good standard form for a few years, otherwise you'll just end up with bad handwriting like me.
Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 109
Thanks:
0
I think you may have misunderstood me. 楷書 did come first.
In short:
1. I have been writing out each kanji stroke by stroke. (seems this is called 楷書).
2. Writing out each kanji stroke by stroke goes rediculously slow (in my opinion anyway) ---> 3. I wanted to find faster ways to write.
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 667
Thanks:
0
The problem with that, as people have pointed out, is that not all simplified handwritten versions of the kanji that you would come up with yourself are valid. There's a specific style to handwritten Japanese that most Japanese actually study in school similarly to how a lot of English speakers study cursive at some point. It's called 習字.
I've been looking for a good 習字 book because, thanks to KanKen, I can write longhand Japanese without breaking out a dictionary every 2 seconds, and now I'm primarily limited by how fast I can actually put the Japanese thoughts down on paper.
My English handwriting is pretty bad, though, too. I should concentrate on both.
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 376
Thanks:
0
I agree with dizmox. Don't try to do anything other than 楷書 until you're very good and reasonably fast at it. Trying to learn other forms too early is asking for trouble. I'm in grad school in Taiwan, and I take my notes by hand mostly in 楷書, as do most of the Taiwanese students in my classes. In fact, many of my Taiwanese friends would struggle to write anything other than 楷書, and they're impressed when I use 行書 or (only occasionally, because I'm not good at it) 草書.
Another thing is, 行書 and 草書 will probably actually be slower at first, because you'll be relearning how to write and you'll have to think about every little curve. Especially if your 楷書 isn't already really good.
Anyway, sometimes the slower way is the better way. Pick up a copy of Björksten's Learn to Write Chinese Characters to learn how to make really nice-looking 楷書 with a pen. It's focused on Chinese, but the principles still apply. There's a book by Fred Wang for Chinese cursive, but I'm guessing Japanese 行書 and 草書 might be a bit different, so I hesitate to recommend it. But at any rate, wait until your 楷書 is really good (really good!) before you try anything else. It's the base upon which everything else is built.