Back

Questions Ending in だ?

#26
By the way guys, I was just reading a Lang-8 entry by one of my friends. In the Japanese version of his entry, he wrote:
'何をやってるんだ!?'
In English, he simply translated this to, "What is he doing?!"

Apparently it is used when angry or distressed. I'm so glad I read that entry ^_^

Sorry for bringing back a dead post.
Reply
#27
Socky Wrote:According to "Tae Kim's Grammar Guide," a question cannot end in the declarative だ, which would seem to make sense. However I faintly remember hearing sentences such as '何をするんだ?' while watching anime. Of course 'da ka' is incorrect, but can you not create a question ending in だ with simply a questioning tone?

Thank you.
FYI:

From Wikipedia concerning the dialect used in Shizuoka Prefecture(遠州弁):
〜だ?
〜の?。話者により、上昇調・下降調のいずれも用いられる。「書いただ?」と言うと、「書いたら?(書いたでしょ?)」と聞き間違えてしまう場合もある。
「昨日、朝ご飯食べただ?」(=「昨日、朝ご飯食べたの?」)
「朝ご飯食べんくて何が悪いだ?」(=「朝ご飯食べなくて何が悪いの?」)

Also, 〜だか is used for questions when a person is talking to his/herself. For example,
昨日、彼は来ただか?

As always, it's depends on the person and whether the environment they grew up in used such language or not.
Reply
#28
kaizer Wrote:I disagree. I've certainly never heard anybody say "What the eff are you doing?" with a sweet voice.
That just means you haven't spent time in Australia yet.
Reply
May 16 - 30 : Pretty Big Deal: Save 31% on all Premium Subscriptions! - Sign up here
JapanesePod101
#29
.
Reply