+- kanji koohii FORUM (http://forum.koohii.com)
+-- Forum: Learning Japanese (http://forum.koohii.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Remembering the Kanji (http://forum.koohii.com/forum-7.html)
+--- Thread: Correct stroke count and order for "tug" (牽) #2550 (/thread-7123.html)
Correct stroke count and order for "tug" (牽) #2550 - Boy.pockets - 2011-01-23
Hey,
I am getting confused with "tug" (牽) #2550. In RTK3, Second edition, he/she says "write crown after the first stroke of that for mysterious. Which would mean that before i complete the top hat, I am already starting on the crown. The dictionary I use all show a different stroke order (though I think they all use the same source). Check out http://www.jisho.org/kanji/details/%E7%89%BD for the stroke count.
My second problem is that although Hesig and the dictionaries say 11 strokes the dictionaries stroke order shows 12 strokes. I am guessing that this is just a mistake of the stroke order, but it is usually the other way around (ie, the font seems to be wrong, but the stroke order diagram seems to be correct).
Tanks.
Correct stroke count and order for "tug" (牽) #2550 - Katsuo - 2011-01-23
Sometimes it's written like this, with 11 strokes.
Correct stroke count and order for "tug" (牽) #2550 - JimmySeal - 2011-01-23
According to the page below, there is an 11-stroke and a 12-stroke version (it shows stroke orders for both), but the 11-stroke version is currently correct:
http://kakijun.main.jp/page/ken200.html
I'm guessing Dr. Heisig meant to say start the crown after the 3rd stroke of mysterious (the 1st stroke of coccoon), but it seems that writing the crown after finishing 玄 is correct, and that does seem to make more sense.
Correct stroke count and order for "tug" (牽) #2550 - Boy.pockets - 2011-01-24
Thanks for the fast reply. I think I will go with the 11 stroke version as it is displayed in the dictionary. I wish things were more standard. Since passing the 2000 mark, there have been many differences in Kanji between the computer fonts and the book.
cheers again.
Correct stroke count and order for "tug" (牽) #2550 - Mesqueeb - 2012-09-24
※「牽」の字形と画数の変遷について
1983年に制定されたJISの字形は12画で、これを元に各種のフォントがデザインされて広まりました。
2004年版では、「JISは字形を規定していない」「JISを国語施策と整合させる」という趣旨で改正が行われています。
例示字形変更前の字形についても、これを即、間違いとするものではありませんので、参考までに12画の「牽」の筆順を下記に示しておきます。
is what Jimmy referred to.