kanji koohii FORUM
A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer - Printable Version

+- kanji koohii FORUM (http://forum.koohii.com)
+-- Forum: Learning Japanese (http://forum.koohii.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: General discussion (http://forum.koohii.com/forum-8.html)
+--- Thread: A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer (/thread-3469.html)



A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer - TheTrueBlue - 2009-07-08

She's a small business owner who commutes daily to NYC from New Jersey who came to the US from Japan a few years back.

At the end of class, I asked if I could please be enlightened as to the meaning of 明鏡止水 meikyoushisui。As a personality trait, I not exactly sure what "clear and serene as a polished/clear mirror 明鏡 or still/stagnant water 止水" means in terms of how a person would act in everyday situations. And are there 木、 火、or 金 equivalents?

Thanks 皆さん。


A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer - Mcjon01 - 2009-07-08

Well, my dictionary supplies "a mind undisturbed [unsullied] by evil thoughts; a serene state of mind" as a definition, if that helps. I'm afraid I can't speak with any authority on your other questions, though.


A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer - thermal - 2009-07-08

My dictionary states:

曇りのない鏡と静かな水。なんのわだかまりもなく、澄みきって静かな心の状態をいう。「—の心境」

Looks similar to "tranquil". "A tranquil state of mind"


A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer - yukamina - 2009-07-08

Yahoo gives this sentence example.

明鏡止水の心境といったところです 
My mind [mental state] is as serene as a polished mirror (and still water).


A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer - Aijin - 2009-07-08

Ah, nothing like an arcane word to spice the day Smile

明鏡止水 is a beautiful term, but you won't see that one too often. Sadly I've probably heard it more in reference to the alcoholic beverage.
I would say "placid" is a better English translation than just "tranquil" though. 明鏡止水 is very meditative, a calm originating from lack of internal and external stimuli. Peace of mind birthed from silence of thought is how I would put it.


A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer - TheTrueBlue - 2009-07-08

どもありがとう皆さん

Yes thank you thermal3 for this description, its exactly what I was looking for.

曇りのない鏡と静かな水。なんのわだかまりもなく、澄みきって静かな心の状態をいう。「—の心境」

Initiate 馬鹿外人 translation skills!

As with a mirror that's not cloudy... As with a peaceful lake... Without anxieties or reserve... A clear and composed heart and spirit is the state of 明鏡止水さん。

So can 明鏡止水 be a temporary state of mind? Or is it more a general descriptor of a kind of person?

Does it mean the ability to stay focused? Or can it be construed as apathy to one's environment? I hope to be able to learn to properly use to use this term and also appreciate its nuances.

And there's a 明鏡止水 beverage?Wow... sounds deep... 


A question my Japanese teacher told me she couldn't answer - bodhisamaya - 2009-07-09

The Buddha is usually painted sitting with a mirror behind him in meditative absorbtion into the clear light nature of mind. All phenomena are realized as illusionary like the moon's reflection on still water.